Great comments on my recent CCL post!
Just to answer a few questions:
1. The new book and materials were released in February/March of 2008. All new CCL courses are now using the new materials. They are still working on the training programs for the “specialized” courses in return of fertility after childbirth and pre-menopause. The student guide book is complete, but the teacher training in these areas is still a little rough. It will be complete in the coming months. The doctor in question was probably referring to the teacher training materials.
2. There is very little difference between Creighton, Billings, and CCL in the actual “rules” of NFP. All 3 methods are 99% effective. CCL teaches the sympto-thermal method of NFP, using all 3 signs (temp, cervix, and mucus). Billings and Creighton focus on mucus only. I personally use a mucus/cervix only method of NFP (CCL gives mucus only rules in their materials, with very clear pictures of more fertile/less fertile mucus), but I teach all 3 signs in my courses, as certain signs work better for certain women. Some women have really regular temp patterns and that enables them to better interpret a confusing mucus pattern (and vice versa). Creighton and Billings are mucus only, but the “rules” are essentially the same (especially after CCL’s updates to their materials). You can take a CCL course, and then do a mucus only method of NFP. CCL’s charts and materials are standardized, and they have many doctors that develop their materials and are trained on CCL charts. That being said, ANY doctor worth anything should be able to read ANY NFP chart. It’s the same thing, just different symbols.
I want to emphasize again that I think all 3 teaching organizations are really great and they are all working together to make NFP more practical for couples.
3. Finally, if you are interested in taking an NFP course you can either contact your local diocese and ask about courses OR you can contact one of the following organizations directly to learn about courses/teachers in your area:
4. The new manual does offer advice on charting with breastfeeding, no matter what feeding method you choose. If this is your situation, I would HIGHLY recommend the supplemental NFP course on return of fertility after childbirth.
5. Finally, if you are looking for an NFP physician, check out the One More Soul Directory for NFP only physicians and if you can’t find a local Obgyn from that directory, try a midwife, they are usually much more knowledgeable about NFP.
God Bless all you women and thanks for all the comments and support!