Is Katherine Heigl’s character poorly written?


Karina Longworth at SpoutBlog has some interesting comments on Knocked Up and the alleged lack of realism therein:

Stepping away from Denby and Emdashes for a moment, this brings us back to the elephant that’s always in the room when talking Knocked Up: the idea that Katherine Heigl’s character is poorly written, because someone like that would never get involved with someone like the character played by Seth Rogen. I know it’s a stretch to ask anyone whose natural analysis of character stops at “Pretty” or “Fat” to think this way, but do you think it’s maybe possible that the Katherine Heigl character was written that way for a reason? Is it so hard to imagine that a woman whose chief asset is her body, whose greatest aspiration is to follow in the footsteps of Giuliana DePandi (no offense to Giuliani), who is clearly lonely as hell (her only friend is apparently her shrewish older sister, who’s clearly occupied with her own pre-midlife crisis) would be lacking in self-confidence and self-worth, and for all of the reasons above, would be attracted to the unconditional love that a baby would represent?

It’s like there some kind of post-feminist block that won’t allow some female critics/viewers to admit that some real-world women are less than total braniacs, and/or that *most* women make decisions from time to time that don’t make total sense, and/or that in real life, attractive-but-dim women often date down the social ladder, picking men who they feel they can control without worrying that they’ll get dumped. At least Seth Rogen’s character showed promising glimpses, signs that he was capable of being genuinely caring, witty and kind. This puts him miles ahead of the average 23-year-old boy.

More interesting thoughts on the film at the link above.

"I remind you, YOU REPLIED to my post that is over 2 years old.I gave ..."

The death, resurrection, and second death ..."
"I believe I have a gut full of your filthy protestants minds that you cannot ..."

The death, resurrection, and second death ..."
"Already replied about archangels. The bible mentions ONLY Michael the archangel in Jude 1:9. If ..."

The death, resurrection, and second death ..."
"Genius I asked you to tell me the names of God's Arch Angel's and while ..."

The death, resurrection, and second death ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment