Whatever Isn’t Love

I was crying again. Sitting in the semi-darkness, the only light coming from the muted TV. Rocking her, always rocking her. My little 3rd child, the one who smiled at me first. The one who cries and cries when not in arms. The one whose body relaxes as I ease her into the Ergo, heart to heart once more. My girl baby who spent all 8 months of pregnancy curled up, belly to belly with mom. She had just finished crying for nearly an hour, our evening ritual of settling down, of physically expelling the stress of the day from her tired little body.

Atticus was on the couch, holding a sleeping Charlie who had a harder than normal transition to bed. My sweet boy. My strong little one who even at 3 days old, only 5 pounds, was holding his head up and straining against me. The one who needs to face out, to take in his world, just as his sister needs to be huddled close to my heart. They may have shared a womb and a birthday, but they are as different as possible, these twins.

Earlier that evening big sister Maggie was jumping on her bed when she should have been getting ready to sleep. She lost her footing and hit her head on the wall. Wailing. “Mommy!”

I ran to her room, baby in arms, to find Dad, baby in arms, trying to comfort her as much as he could. When you have two infants and a three year old, there aren’t enough arms for all of the little hearts who want to be held. I set down her sister, which began that tiny infant cry we have grown so used to hearing, the sound of defeat. The sound of, “You can’t please all the people all the time” and “Sometimes someone has to cry”. Mary Cate drew the short straw.

I scooped my firstborn, my gingersnap, my Maggie, into my arms. I kissed her head and gently tucked her into bed. She held my hand in hers and said, “I love you Mommy.” This girl is all heart. She wears her emotions on her sleeve, and in that way, has inherited more than just my eyes. She relishes her role as big sister, and loves “her babies” fiercely. But tonight, she needed to be the baby. She needed me, and only me, and all of me, to soothe her tired head. We read her favorite stories (this week: Sofia, Frozen, and Everyday Dress Up). We snuggled close, this amazing child who steals my heart and tries my patience. Everyday, she does this. My child that I struggled the most to connect with, the most to love. Turns out she is so much like me, and now my heart swells at the sight of her sleeping soundly.

I walked out of her room, and back to the living room, back to screaming Mary Cate.

Then I cried.

I said to Atticus,

“These children are literally shaving years and years off of my stint in purgatory.”  I like to use humor to deflect my emotions.

His response?

“They sure are. That is their job.” He is never particularly wordy.

Then I said, voice shaking, “I don’t know if I can do this anymore.”

This. The relentlessness washing over me, a bed of river rock being worn down by their endless need. There isn’t a moment when I’m awake when someone doesn’t need me, or when I’m not working to keep our family afloat. Even now, I’m only able to write this because of the generous gift of time, given by my mother-in-law.

Atticus, he’s a smart man. I love that about him. But what I love even more, is that he is so wise. He shut down my one-woman pity party with a few short sentences.

“You can do this, because you have done it. Every day for the past 9 weeks. You will do it, because you love them. You just want to quit because its hard.”

Of course I want to quit because its hard; that’s the human condition. So has every person who has ever run a marathon, or written a symphony, gotten a PhD, or fought in a war. Every single thing that’s worth doing in life is hard. Everybody wants to quit sometimes. Fallen human nature seeks to flee from every kind of suffering, even the kind that is short-lived and comes hand in hand with joy. That is why, even though I wanted these babies with every piece of my heart, I also want to run screaming from the house at least once a day.

But I don’t. I don’t leave. I do the best I can for these little terrorists, knowing that they are capable of giving very little in return. In a Dar Williams song, she says:

“What do you love more than love? When the giving is all that you ever get back, oh how do I love like that? Can you tell me, oh, how to love?”

And Heaven, Heaven is the place where everything that isn’t love has been burned away. Heaven is to be in the presence of a God who is love, and nothing more. Purgatory is the state of being where everything that isn’t love is burned away.

These little people, they force me to confront my own selfishness. How I greedily hoard my time, like Gollum with an hourglass. They hold up a mirror to my face, and I cannot turn away. I have to see the lack of patience, the places where my heart is full of anything but love. They overwhelm me, they push me farther than I thought I could go. And they’re saving me. Every day that goes by when I put them ahead of myself, when I give up what I want in order to give them what they need, a piece of myself that isn’t love is burned away. Every day that goes by when I love them – imperfectly, but sincerely – is one day closer to Heaven.

I have wondered more than once why he trusted me with these twins and their sister. That I’m impatient, selfish, and passionate. That I’m not cut out for this motherhood stuff. God doesn’t see that when he sees me. He sees the mother I can be, when those damaged parts are burned away. He knows that the purification happens only in the mothering, only in the doing.

He know what he is about.



"Going through this in a small way- God has been preventing us from getting pregnant ..."

When Generosity Looks Like Selfishness
"You're right Sarah...where did "that" Catholicism go? Those pictures you show really make you think. ..."

Where Are Our Leaders?
"As heart-wrenching as it is to say, there is still racism within the Church hierarchy. ..."

Where Are Our Leaders?
"Really lovely, thank you!"

Litany of NFP Saints

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Jeanne G.

    This is just awesome <3

  • http://adashofsnark.blogspot.com Madeline

    This is beautiful, true and exactly what I needed to read today. Thank you.

  • Kristin

    I really loved this…and I love you, too! :)

  • joymhb


    And that desire to do it well; that recognition that those babies are a gift and a responsibility will carry you so far. You’ve got this!

  • http://twitter.com/octoberrose octoberrose

    A friend of mine passed along your blog post because we, too, have a young toddler and now twin infants. Thank you for writing it. It does my heart good to see words put to it so beautifully.

  • http://motheringspirit.wordpress.com Laura

    Right there with you. I still feel versions of this emotional roller coaster every day. Infertility and miscarriage pile on the guilt of “I should be relishing every second of this.” But I don’t. Because it’s hard. So exhausting. Even when you love them more than life. I don’t have any good advice, only solidarity. I love it when other moms speak their truth on this because I am right.there.too.

  • Pat

    Someday– Put all of this into a novel or a memoir!! I love your writing.

  • Emily G

    At my house, I have 3 toddlers. And infant twins. There is just not enough of me to go around. It’s hard, very hard. I never used to talk to myself, maybe I’m going nuts :) , but I say to myself at least once a day, “You can do this. You have been doing it. You are doing it now. And you will continue to do it.”

  • Maggie Mizelle

    Sarah, I’m hopelessly behind on blogs these days, but I read this last week and keep marking as unread in my reader (kind of a tongue twister!). It moved me in ways that I can’t quite describe. Put words to feelings that I have daily – hourly, even – and could never have expressed. Helped me not feel so alone in this motherhood experience that I desperately wanted but find harder and less fulfilling at times than I could ever have imagined. And gave me hope and reassurance. Thank you, from the bottom of my heart.

  • http://nakednosh.tumblr.com Sheila LaMaster

    Sarah, this is beautifully written and awesome and true. well said. thanks so much for writing this! I thought I had read all of your recent posts but must have missed this amazing one.