In Another Lifetime

Early one recent morning, I’m still half-asleep. The cat lies curled up between Craig and me, and when my leg moves against her, she snarls.

“Hey, now, little one,” he says, bending his face down to her and scratching her softly behind the neck. “That’s not the way to act, is it?”

In my sleepy state, I hear him talking to a child, our child. “You would’ve made such a good father,” I think as I fall back to sleep, drowsy logic catching on my use of the conditional.

A year ago, when we went to our first session of church-mandated premarital counseling, the therapist advised us to discuss the two most-cited sources of marital discord: money and children—“or child-rearing,” she qualified, glancing at the information sheet. “Do either of you have children from a previous relationship?” We shook our heads. “Are you two thinking about having children?” She glanced at the form again, at the space in which I’ve written my age, and quickly added, “either your own or adopting?”

Earlier this year, a few months after our wedding, Craig and I attended a baptism. The priest had just asked the parents why they’d brought their babies to the altar. “To be accepted into the body of Christ,” they answered. I choked up. Partly because of the struggle the parents went through to bring those babies into the world; also because the ancient sacrament never fails to move me. As many times as I’d heard the Rite of Baptism performed from the Book of Common Prayer, that Saturday, I was listening for the first time—to words not from the BCP but from a blue pamphlet handed out beforehand in this Catholic parish run by the Salesians.

Later, on our walk home, Craig said, “I wish we’d met ten years earlier, especially on a day like today.” I knew what he meant. A day when we’d witnessed babies being baptized. If we’d met ten years earlier, we’d have probably been able to have children of our own, watched trickles of holy water run down their soft scalps as they were accepted into the body of Christ.

Those days have passed us by. I no longer try to pretend otherwise. But occasionally, as at that baptism, I find myself facing what feels less like acceptance and more like a choice not to think too much about it.

Every night for months, I’ve pushed a small green-yellow tablet through its blister. Yes, I’m fifty, but as the tough-voiced receptionist at my gynecologist’s office told me before I went on the low-dose birth-control pill, “If you still get your period, you can get pregnant.”

The advice was straight out of seventh-grade sex education but I’d wanted to believe otherwise.

“What are you doing for birth control?” she asked.

Nothing, I admitted.

Her voice got even more businesslike. “Well, first thing you do, is come in and take a pregnancy test.”

“I really don’t think I’m pregnant.”

“When was your last period?”

“Months ago.”

Silence, and I heard my voice through her ears. Did I really sound so irresponsible, so in denial? I’ve always considered myself responsible and no-nonsense on matters of contraception, not someone to take a chance. So what was going on here?

I was almost the same age as the Oldest Woman to Give Birth listed in my 1971 edition of the Guinness Book of World Records. (Now, of course, we’d have to add a footnote—to give birth to a baby conceived with her own eggs and fertilized and gestated in her own womb.) I’d met the man I would marry. And I was imagining myself in maternity wear, colors to paint a nursery, what we’d do about kindergarten.

I’d assumed that the odds of conceiving were nil—but of course they weren’t. Small, but not nil. And suddenly, that tiny percentage bloomed a myriad of possibilities, both giddy and troubling.

What if I did conceive, after all—at my age, well, what then? I couldn’t cite the exact odds on chromosomal abnormalities in babies born to women over forty-five, but I had a general idea they didn’t fall in my favor. And then what? Some decisions I never wanted to have to make. And yet, by not taking any precautions, I had made a decision, hadn’t I? And, later, by going on the pill, I made another.

We, I should say. I didn’t make those decisions alone. One night, we went back and forth:

“I can barely run with my bad hip. Will I be able to play catch with my kid when I’m sixty-five?”

“Do you like Elizabeth Ellen as a girl’s name?”

“I’ll be seventy-seven when he’s twenty-one.”

“He? Who said it would be a boy?”


We’ve accepted the fact we won’t have children, either our own or adopted. We’re OK with it. The topic didn’t take up a whole lot of counseling, premarital or otherwise. But every day, one way or another, we mourn our childlessness. Not always consciously, and not always strongly. Sometimes it’s relief at having flexibility in our schedules, more time for each other. But whenever we pass babies on the street, we catch each other’s eyes.

Sometimes one of us says something. Yes, it’s too bad we didn’t meet ten years earlier—but isn’t it good we didn’t meet ten years later? And other times, we just squeeze hands.

Lindsey Crittenden is the author of The Water Will Hold You: A Skeptic Learns to Pray and The View from Below: Stories. Her essays, short fiction, and articles have appeared in the New York Times, the San Francisco Chronicle, Image, Bellingham Review, The Best American Spiritual Writing, and other publications. She lives in San Francisco, where she teaches writing at UC Berkeley Extension. Her website

"Mass incarceration wouldn't be happening if black men didn't commit so much crime. Fix the ..."

Lynching, Racial Terror, and Black Liberation ..."
"STEAMER! adding Environment!!"

Replace STEM with STAR
"Such a wonderful piece! So full of nuance, dense imagery and word play. I love ..."

In the Presence of My Enemies
"Thank you for the homily of hope. Thank you for not being as discouraged, and ..."

A Sky of Parchment Made

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Heidi Sohng

    Thank you for your honesty. It makes me feel even more grateful for my little one, whom I had at 42 – I feel like I just scraped by on that one. I don’t think I’ll have more children because of my age, which makes me sad, but no more sadder than you. Thanks for sharing again.

    • Lindsey Crittenden

      Thanks for writing, Heidi. I’m glad you did.

  • Dear Lindsey,
    Your writing here always resonates with me and I wish I could construct a fabulous comment that would in some way say more than “thanks for writing this.” Here’s (another) quote from Writing True that I think describes your writing: “It’s the struggle with complexity, more than ‘the big answer’ that challenges nonfiction writers….” Thank you for sharing your struggle with complexity with us.


    • Lindsey Crittenden

      And I wish, Callie, that I could construct a fabulous comment to say more than “thanks for commenting.” But I do thank you, once more. And I’m glad to find the reminder about complexity in nonfiction writing–about grappling, about asking rather than answering.

  • Deb

    We also made the decision not to have children, though we made it in our 20’s and again in our 30’s, just as our friends were getting around to getting married and having children. I have health issues, my husband wasn’t sure he wanted children. We often thought we could adopt, and therefore it wouldn’t be a biological decision for us. We could adopt any time. Meanwhile, I had a hysterectomy and was diagnosed with yet another illness I wouldn’t want to pass on to children. I knew I couldn’t rear children with as much physical affection and attention as they needed, and so adoption soon moved off the table. And finally my biological clock started ticking, here in my mid-30’s. And I question our decision. But deep inside we really don’t feel called to be parents. That could change, but it hasn’t in 15 years of marriage. Still I wonder and question when I see baptisms, or meet a friend’s newborn, or see folks on the street. It hurts, but it is the right decision.

    • Lindsey Crittenden

      Hi Deb: You bring up an important point–that emotions don’t settle (or stop) just because we make a decision, even the right one. It sounds like you & husband’s decision was more conscious than ours, in honoring that inner voice. I think it’s a measure of the texture of the fabric of life that as comfortable as we are with certain choices, the wondering never stops. Thanks for writing.