Herod Lives — on Twitter

Twitter is a funny thing I still haven’t figured out how to use well. In one sense it could be considered an example of some of the worst of the modern age, encouraging the attention-deficit-disorder lifestyles of the era.

But it presents this opportunity to catch people in a moment. They’re in a cab or on an elevator and a 140-character tweet can grab them, draw them in for one reason or another.

Maybe that’s delusional. I think that, sometimes — that Twitter could really truly be more bad than good. But then I wonder; I wonder especially when I get some of the ugliest tweets in response.

So yesterday I could have just turned off my Ipad completely. But I decided to tweet some meditation lines from the church where I found listening to and thus meditating on the last words of Christ.

(Well, meditating while tweeting … )

And so I shared a little. And boy did it seem to annoy people on Twitter (apologies to the people sitting behind me, too), bringing out words from them Christ did not quite say on the Cross.

The responses (the f word used was not faith) reminded me of a conversation I had months ago with Father Robert Barron, who created that wonderful Catholicism series. (More here and here on that.)

I asked him if online engagement is really worth it. It can be ugly. You do not always know who you are reaching (which of course can be an argument both against and for engagement — think of Rick Santorum’s C-SPAN Miracle story).

“There is a spiritual longing. I’m an Augustinian – your heart is restless until it rests in God,” Fr. Barron said in response. “It’s the most fundamental perception. I see that all. The. time. Everyone’s searching for a perfect goodness and a perfect justice. What’s animating us whatever we’re doing is a desire for truth.”

“Everyone is hungry for God,” he asserted. “They may not know it. They may not be able to articulate it. That’s the Church’s job in a way to say: ‘Hey, this is what you’re looking for. You’re looking for God.’”

Echoing Cardinal Dolan in his WSJ interview the other day, Fr. Barron told me (and goodness knows I have seen it with my own eyes): “I see that everywhere. In young people. Especially on the Internet. (Some of them are obscene of course, I don’t respond to those.) They are mostly young men. Young men who will engage me on the Internet …  there are a great number, I think, who are reaching out. Who might come across a bit hostile at first. But they’re interested in the question of God. And I’m thinking about God and they know that. And they’ve taken the time to watch a video [on his Word on Fire site] and to respond.”

“Okay, I’ll engage you,” Fr. Barron said, explaining his pastoral approach to these communications. “Let’s talk. I’ll argue with you if I think you’re wrong … or I tell you where you can expand your thinking or so on.”

“I get that all the time, I see young people secularized, born in this secular culture. But who are looking,” he said. “And they are really looking seriously. I find that encouraging.”

I then asked him “What would you say to people who are engaging in the culture? Who get way too much of the kind of obscene/hostile kind of response. How do you keep doing it? Why is it worth it?”

“I get that — because I get that all the time too,” he shared. “Years ago I did a little video on corruption. And the word ‘corruption’ was in the title of the video. So a guy wrote in, anonymously, and he said, ‘Does anyone get the irony of this? I can’t imagine anyone more corrupt than a Catholic priest.’ I wake up in the morning, I see that. I get that. And it is wearying.” He recalled writing something “utterly benign” about praying for Christopher Hitchens that ignited a firestorm, thousands of responses. He found it even a “little bit” shocking. You do sometimes get, online, “punishingly negative responses from people. Even in that is a hunger for God,” Fr. Barron reminded me.

He talked about his “Herod Principle,” which I couldn’t help but have on my mind on Good Friday night. This is how he put in a piece about CNN’s Belief website, responding to the impressive angry, atheist presence in the comments there:

We shouldn’t imitate the Internet atheists in their nastiness, but we should certainly imitate them in our willingness to come forward boldly and showing some intellectual teeth. But the fierce and vocal presence of so many atheists on the CNN Belief Blog and so many other religious sites also speaks to what I call the Herod Principle.

The Gospels tell us that Herod Antipas arrested John the Baptist because the prophet had publicly challenged the King. Herod threw John into prison but then, we are told, the King loved secretly to listen to the prophet, who continued to preach from his cell.

St. Augustine formulated an adage that beautifully sums up the essentials of Christian anthropology: “O Lord, you have made us for yourself; therefore our hearts are restless until they rest in you.” A basic assumption of Biblical people is that everyone is hard-wired for God in the measure that everyone seeks a fulfillment that cannot be had through any of the goods of this world. Long before Augustine, the psalmist prayed, “only in God is my soul at rest.”

My wager, as a person of faith, is that everyone — at that includes Christopher Hitchens, Bill Maher, and Richard Dawkins — implicitly wants God and hence remains permanently fascinated by the things of God. Though the fierce atheists of today profess that they would like to eliminate religious speech and religious ideas, secretly they love to listen as people speak of God. This goes a long way, it seems to me, toward explaining their presence in great numbers on religious blogs.

So I say to Christians and other believers: be ready for a good fight, and get some spiritual weapons in your hands. And I say to the atheists: I’ll keep talking — because I know, despite all of your protestations and sputtering, that your hearts are listening.

“Love your enemies,” Fr. Barron reminded me during our interview, around the time Catholicism was about to launch. Christ, of course, delivered that message yesterday with His very life.

Living through Good Friday 2012, I can’t help but think we’re not even in full-on enemy territory yet — until the Obama administration starts martyring people for not wanting to pay for the supposed fundamental human right that is government-subsidized birth control, sterilization, and abortion-inducing drugs. It’s hard but it’s not yet that hard. Others before us have been asked to do a lot more than engage online! Or even protest a radically secularist administration intent — however well-intentioned some of the architects may be — on eroding the religious liberties of all Americans. With a little love and a lot of work, with our eyes fixed on Christ on the Cross,  who is all good and defeats all evil, it’s actually relatively simple — inasmuch as trusting in our Father is the key.

Into your hands Lord, I commend my spirit.

Even on Twitter.

  • http://gmsplace.com GM Roper

    K-Lo, you have touched my heart. Thank you!

  • Pingback: Sunday Morning Grumpy Daily Headline News | Grumpy Opinions

  • Clifford Robards

    It is one of the hardest things to do. Forgive your enemies but it is the only way to live. To forgive and ask his forgiveness leads you the the right path to live and love.

  • Phyllis Hobbs

    Loved your article!!!

  • Plzl

    Great article Kathryn! Don’t you just love Father Robert? I know that God smiles upon him each day…..

  • Linda

    From my experience blogging in the past (political commentary informed by by Catholic worldview) I would concur with all that you say. The comments could be very hurtful, but I did my best to answer with truth and charity – though the latter was always a challenge – a snide comeback would often get the better of me… Humility is always a challenge!

  • Jared

    I’ve been preparing to spread the Word in the harsh, secular wasteland that is the internet (praying, reading apologetics, and more praying). This piece has some great advice and I will think back on it when times are tough. Thank you!

  • http://www.tumblr.com/blog/davewelch21 David Welch

    Wonderful article. Father Barron is my hero!

  • Lar

    Some people may not be reachable, K-Lo. At least not by you or me [certainly by the Holy Spirit]. But in the online world it’s not the trolls we need to keep in mind as much as the lurkers. They are the ones, the quiet anonymous readers, who we really are evangelizing with every response. They will see and respond to good logical arguments but also, even more so, to charitable ones.

  • cheryl

    way behind on my reading, but really enjoyed this article, KJL.

  • Karen

    Amen…

  • http://www.patheos.com/blogs/kathrynlopez/2012/04/herod-lives-on-twitter/ Carla

    Years ago, I remember thinking, as I was on Catholic Answers waiting for my blog to be posted, the standard message it would give me is “you are being taken to your post.” I thought of it as the equivelant (or maybe worse), of the whipping posts that you still see standing in Europe. I couldn’t tolerate the spiritual pain that it put me in, anymore. It wasn’t that I didn’t have the spiritual tools, it was the nastiness. There was this aetheist who was following me all over the site, in order to retort and defend his lack of belief. I had to finally get him removed. Not a nice experience.

  • Barry

    My question is this, “How do you destroy a society”? You eat it from the inside out! What I mean is this. The US was founded on religous freedom and christianity but there are those who do not believe and want what is only good for them. Power, Greed, Money, the bottom line, Materialism! All of what you see going on in this country started a long time ago. Look at the ones behind the scenes and there you will find your answer. A scociety is not destroyed, removed, changed and rearranged by war. It is purposely done through infiltration.
    I am Catholic and will fight to the bitter end to get this point across.
    God Bless you all!!!!

  • http://www.marinenz.org.nz/index.php/member/424303/ makeup free samples

    Thank you for your blog.Really looking forward to read more. Fantastic.


CLOSE | X

HIDE | X