One Lord, One Faith, One Music

In The Whole Church Sings (41), Robin Leaver summarizes Andreas Karlstadt’s 53 theses against Gregorian chant (1521):

“It is a consecutive tirade, not particularly well-organized, against all forms of liturgical music then current, not just Gregorian chant, which is dismissed as the ‘mumblings of the unlearned’ (Thesis 31). Chant sung in the Mass and daily Office ‘withdraws the mind from God’ (Thesis 7) and is ‘nothing other than a noisy din’ (Thesis 14). Organs and other musical instruments are for theaters (theatra chorearum) and the courts of princes, not for churches (Theses 17-18). And any ‘church music with a measured beat’ is absolutely proscribed ‘as the most effective obstacle to devotions’ (Thesis 16).”

Amid all this criticism is one proposal: “If therefore you wish music to stay in the church, you should will it to be sung in unison, so that there may be one God, one Baptism, one faith and one music” (Thesis 53).

Leaver sums up: “Since Karlstadt has dismissed all forms of church music then known – Gregorian chant in the Mass, the Psalm tones of the daily Office, polyphony and the use of instruments – the only model he is left with is the vernacular strophic religious folk song.”

Which, Leaver argues, is exactly what Luther and others used as the basis for Reformation hymnody.

"Geez, Dreher's article is ridiculous. Basically, persecution is coming. Persecution, of course, is defined as ..."

"Do you truly believe that atheists, agnostics, or even non-Christians don't have a shared sense ..."

Liberalism’s Soul
"I have never heard of a Christian in America who desires persecution. I have read ..."

"We have both fred and Carl nietztche. You can't separate the two they are dopplegangers. ..."

Poetics of Final Judgment

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment