Peter T. Chattaway has been threatening to write an article about just how much pagan mythology is scattered throughout The Chronicles of Narnia, and I hope he does it. There has been a lot written about why Narnia is “good” and Harry Potter’s world is “bad,” but the situation isn’t nearly that simple. There are so many similarities between the two series, and I think Chattaway’s going to highlight that for us one of these days. At least, I hope he does. Someone should.
Today, he scratches the surface:
I am intrigued to see how Aslan and Bacchus and the Maenads and all the other “Old Narnians”, in their quest to revive a sort of baptized paganism and to defeat modernity in Narnia, destroy a couple of schools. And I am intrigued to see how Lewis describes the children at those schools as being very fat.
I am intrigued by this because J.K. Rowling’s mercilessly comical depiction of Harry Potter’s fat cousin Dudley, including the bit where Hagrid gives him a pig’s tail, was one of many, many things that Richard Abanes criticized her for, in his book Harry Potter and the Bible: The Menace behind the Magick — an impressively thorough collection of reasons to dislike Rowling’s books. And this was one of the few Abanes criticisms that I actually thought might have some merit! To quote my review of Abanes’s book:
Although he makes some valid points, Abanes is so determined to find evil in Rowling’s books that he neglects their better qualities; and when he assesses Lewis and Tolkien, he has nothing but praise — even though their writings contain many of the things he finds so offensive in the Potter books.
Serenity is first and foremost a rowdy, exciting sci-fi romp with few pretensions beyond providing two hours of crafty genre thrills. At one point, Mal, with typically straightforwardness, says to his crew, “All right, let’s have no fussin’.” And throughout, Serenity exemplifies the no-fuss film, largely by decrying the biggest fuss of them all — a callous, overbearing government.
Suderman also contributes a thoughtful look at Elizabethtown, one of the best-written film reviews I’ve ever seen published at Relevant.
And what’s more, he’s getting into the interesting debate over the merits of Quentin Tarantino‘s hyperviolent storytelling.