Zac Alstin…

tackles the problem of the ad hominem fallacy.

The problem is this: “Joe’s wrong because he’s ugly” is a worthless ad hominem, but “Joe’s wrong because he’s a stupid bigot” *might* be fallacious, but it might also have some merit since a pattern of stupid bigotry can, in fact, alter and even destroy Joe’s thinking and argumentation about the object of his bigotry. This is why a wise man does not credit David Duke on the subject of race relations or turn to Hitler for insights on the Jews.

"They probably do. It's an unavoidable consequence of this culture war nonsense. I don't have ..."

Interviewed Rebecca Bratten Weiss on Connecting ..."
"Not fighting Pope Francis then, just the *entire* Vatican ..."

Interviewed Rebecca Bratten Weiss on Connecting ..."
"I'm assuming they are speaking about the politics in the Vatican currently...i.e. Scandals, the St ..."

Interviewed Rebecca Bratten Weiss on Connecting ..."
"" It is clear the Vatican does not care about the Church’s traditional teachings and ..."

Interviewed Rebecca Bratten Weiss on Connecting ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • ivan_the_mad

    Well worth the read.

  • Ted Seeber

    I was just listening to Chesterton on the subject of “the Jewish problem”, from _The New Jerusalem_ librivox this morning- and suddenly I understand Hitler’s real problem with the Jews and the Catholics is the same as Obama’s problem with the Catholics. Not so much bigotry and hatred, as being beholden to an idea beyond the vision and paradigm of the leader.