Conscience vs. bishops

Over the at the Register, a reader puzzles about what to do when his conscience tells him to ignore his bishop. Adventures ensue.

"“For in him we live, and move, and have our being” — Acts 17:28"

Your Thomistic Coolness for Today
"I think something more in line with comparable industrialized countries rather tha Yemen or El ..."

The interchangeability of Gun Cult and ..."
"This is really old, but it also suggests that (again) I was really lowballing it: ..."

The interchangeability of Gun Cult and ..."
"Principle of double effect. Does not involve intentional killing."

The Sheer Orwellianism of Crisis

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • http://commonsensecatholicism.blogspot.com/ Kevin Tierney

    Pretty simple:

    Is the command from the Bishop causing you to sin? If it is, then resist it. If not, and meeting it is possible, then you do it, even if you don’t like it.

  • Peggy

    As far as anti-discrimination laws regarding homosexuals is concerned, this reader may want consider that such a law could prevent a Catholic entity from refusing to hire or from firing a homosexual particularly one who is in a visible position with children, ie, Catholic school. Thus, such a law could inhibit the Catholic entity’s religious freedom. So, he may want to heed his bishop’s guidance here.

    He should read the particulars of the proposed law and his bishop’s explanation for opposition to the proposed law.