No Country for Muslim Women

I am not an Islamic scholar, therefore my opinions on Islam do not count. Worse still,  I’m told that it’s not my place to have an opinion on Islam at all.

This is the general climate of thought in Malaysia put forth in the recent proposal by the country’s main Islamic party, PAS, to investigate the Muslim feminist non-governmental organization Sisters In Islam (SIS) for un-Islamic activities and to “rehabilitate” its members to “the right path”. The announcement has sent shock waves across the country.

The feminist organization has long been the thorn on many Muslim Malaysians’ sides, of both conservative and moderate persuasions, mainly for their outspoken critique of book-banning, polygamy, and state-imposed concepts of modesty. The latest in the string of attacks against SIS is by far the most extreme and is said by many to be a major political misstep for PAS, which once vowed to be “modern” and “democratic”.

But PAS has yet to retract their demands amidst growing pressure from many quarters, including criticisms from within party lines. But more importantly, it has yet to disclose further details of their charges against SIS. In the meantime, their contempt for Sisters In Islam touches on more personal issues that raises questions as to whether accusations against them are really from a theological standpoint; from the members’ choice of dress (many do not wear the hijab) and marital status (many are also unmarried). These claims to discredit SIS have been reactionary at best, intolerant and anti-women at worst.

Calls for SIS to drop “Islam” from their name cite the non-governmental organization’s lack of formal credentials to represent the religion and influence to mislead young minds. But who has the right to represent Islam? And really, do we need an authoritative body to speak for a community so complex and pluralistic, especially when ones that claim to do so have shown themselves, time and time again, to be petty and bigoted?

Being a Muslim feminist and a supporter of the organization, I have a different view: the “Islam” in SIS denotes the reclamation of certain rights from Islamic sources, by reading the Quran and hadiths from a gender-neutral perspective. It certainly is not about representing every Muslim man and woman in Malaysia as more “authoritative” voices would claim. Put simply, “Islam” in SIS is about women who live in an Islamic state, politically and spiritually.

Muslim feminists have long been targets of brutal attacks. Many have even lost their lives for promoting women’s rights: Turkish feminist writer Konca Kuris openly expressed her critical views on male domination in her society and paid with her life in 1998. Asma Jahangir, Nawal al-Sadaawi, and the women of RAWA, for example, have all received numerous death threats. The long list of Muslim activists can testify that what the women and men of SIS believe in are not freakish coincidences or “alien” to modern-day Islam.

But it is what they believe in that’s viewed as dangerous. So dangerous that a member of Malaysian parliament suggested that the organization should be investigated under the Shariah Criminal Offenses Enactments and the penal code, as if the members were criminal suspects. And so as it stands, the easiest and most cowardly way to containing that danger is by silencing them.

When religion is deeply entrenched in the country’s constitution and public policies, everyone has a right to talk about it, and particularly, to criticise its abuse. But the threat to express dissent hangs over every Malaysian like a foreboding black cloud. “Liberal” has become a dirty word in Malaysia, where it can mean anything from being Westernised and elitist, to simply being immoral.

To demonise organisations like SIS for being “liberal” for expressing non-mainstream opinions pertaining to Islam is more than just clichéd, it’s about bullying the usual “soft” targets like women and other marginalized communities into silent submission.

A Potential Burqa Ban at the Federal Level in Switzerland
Friday Links | December 19, 2014
Will Jordanian Hind Al Fayez Sit Down? A Look at the Trending Hashtag #Sit_Down_Hind
The Latest on the Headscarf “Situation” in Switzerland
  • Sobia

    “I’m told that it’s not my place to have an opinion on Islam at all.
    This is the general climate of thought in Malaysia put forth…. ”

    This is the general climate in most places.

    I still wonder why women are seen as such threats to society. No matter what we do, we will always be seen as responsible for the destruction, or possible destruction, of society. Forget the fact that it’s been men who’ve instigated most destructive acts.

  • clare

    This is terrible (although sadly not that surprising). While there is certainly a place for scholars, Islam belongs to everyone.
    I am checking out the website for Sisters in Islam to send a donation or an email of support-
    Thanks for the information & the very true commentary.

  • Rochelle

    This is bullshit. Sisters in Islam deserves everyone’s support, as they are a ballin’ organization.

  • Mohammed

    I will also sent a donation/support for Sisters in Islam! Its gender-neutral perspective is viewed as dangerous to the male dominate perspective. But this is not new, generally Muslim women are excluded and when they do engage they are marginalized. And now Muslim women who express dissent are also persecuted. Even when the Quran says it came for all people including the illiterate and it encourages each one of us to use our own intellect to understand its verses. This includes women that make up 50% of any population. So why should we allow only a few to define it for us? And why should we allow only males to define it and not females?

    Muslim women organization have as much right to public dialogue as others without being persecuted.

  • Pingback: Authority, the Media, and Muslim Women « Muslimah Media Watch()

  • Pingback: The Mother of All Sins: Kartika Sari Dewi Shukarno’S Caning « Muslimah Media Watch()

  • Pingback: Mother of all sins: the caning of Kartika Sari Dewi « Cycads()