2 years ago: Joe Carter says facts and truth are subjective matters of opinion

October 19, 2011, here on slacktivist: Joe Carter says facts and truth are subjective matters of opinion

Were Thomas Jefferson, John Adams, Benjamin Franklin and Thomas Paine “evangelicals who intended America to be a Christian nation”? Giberson and Stephens would say no, in fact, they were not evangelicals and they did not intend America to be a Christian nation. Joe Carter [of First Things] says “think for yourself” — what do you want to be true? Go with that and don’t let any sophomoric, bias-confirming facts sway you one way or the other.

Is climate change “real and caused by humans”? Giberson and Stephens look at the evidence and say that yes, in fact, it is. Carter says this slavish devotion to evidence and fact is just another form of “fundamentalism.” Free your mind and the facts will follow.

What seems to have upset Carter the most in their op-ed was their criticism of James Dobson for advocating “reparative therapy.” Carter, oddly, cites a study that he says claims to show that reparative therapy works. So, wait, suddenly studies and evidence and science matter? Because just a minute ago Carter said they didn’t. This reflects another great advantage to rejecting reason and reality — you don’t need to worry about consistency. If Carter isn’t concerned with contradicting reality, then he doesn’t need to be concerned with contradicting himself either.

  • Hexep

    I wish I had some kind of magic weapon, whereby I could reach out with it, strike a nerve or synapse inside Joe Carter’s head, and thereby compel him to the most dismal sadness and weeping for a long, long time. He seems like he deserves to have something to weep over, but I don’t want to actually break anything or hurt anybody.


CLOSE | X

HIDE | X