I’m Against Gambling

It may come as a surprise to some readers who think me a libertine, that I think gambling is bad for society, and I oppose it.  I especially oppose it as a state-sanctioned fundraiser.

Here in Minnesota, our last governor was a nice, conservative evangelical, who consistently pitched more casinos as an answer to our state’s budget woes.  Thankfully, his ideas never took.

Now all the buzz around here is about the Vikings threatening to leave the state if we don’t build them a new stadium.  The stupidity of this debate leaves me speechless.  Especially when the leading idea to pay the state’s share is to move gambling off of Indian reservations and into downtown Minneapolis.

In a rare cooperative effort, both liberal and conservative Christians in Minnesota are working against this idea:

Brian Rusche, Joint Religious Legislative Council executive director, testified recently before two state Senate committees, telling lawmakers that significant social costs come with gambling, including addiction, family violence, divorce as well as police and court expenses. He told me later that gambling “utterly preys on desperation.”

Tom Prichard, president of the Minnesota Family Council and who also testified at the Capitol hearing, agrees. “There’s a spill-over effect. It breaks up families, causes crime and divorce,” he said

If Vegas wants to thrive on this blight, so be it.  But any increase in gambling will erode the good life in Minnesota.

  • Kevin Douglas

    I love that the ads I get reading this post are for Horseshoe casino here in Chicago!

  • Steve

    We’re currently waging that fight here in Massachusetts, where our Democratic governor just signed a landmark bill authorizing expanded gambling throughout the state. Several urban areas are possible locations for a casino/slot parlor, including my own. Many people here are deluded / mislead into believing this will be a huge boon to the state’s economy (reality: other states are bailing out their casinos; economic benefit projections are overblown) AND have a miniscule impact on our way of life (reality: social, traffic, real estate, crime, financial problems will affect us all). It’s beyond me how blind some are to this issue.

  • Tom

    I agree with you, Tony. I’m a member of the United Methodist Church, which opposes gambling and has opposed the building of casinos in Gary, Indiana. The casinos were sold as a way to “save” Gary, an area that has been blighted since the US steel industry collapsed. Instead it brought low-income jobs along with all the other negatives of gambling that you mention. Personally, I don’t gamble in casinos nor play the state lottery. I have bought lottery tickets in the past, but always came away with the feeling that I had just been duped out of my money. No more.

  • http://jaschroeder.blogspot.com Jesse

    The argument in Ohio is JOBS JOBS JOBS. The casinos are being built in parts of town that used to thrive, by now are struggling, and so the hope is that it will bring jobs, both in the casino and surrounding businesses.

  • http://www.noren-hentz.com Todd Noren-Hentz

    Long time reader, first time commenter here…Thanks for your thoughtfully provocative blog.

    I think I’ve been living with a double standard in my own ethical outlook on gambling. From a “personal sin” perspective, I’ve got no problem at all with the activity of combining risk, strategy, and exchange of property in this thing we call gambling. From a “social sin” perspective, I agree, Tony, gambling is effectively a regressive tax and hurts society in a number of ways.

    In seminary, I played poker with friends weekly and won enough money to buy my wife a wedding ring. Was it wrong? I’ve never felt like it was. But if I oppose things like my state, Alabama, funding education with a lottery, am I paternalistic for permitting myself to gamble, yet opposing the same freedom for others – particularly poor people who may spend the money they need for food, bills, etc. on lottery tickets?

    For now, I’m living in the grey and just admitting my paternalism…

    • http://tonyj.net Tony Jones

      Todd, I’m with you. I play poker on occasion as well, though I’m not very good. I’m more opposed to state-endorsed gambling.

  • Vallen

    I agree with you, but is there a grey area? I am from one of these reservations in MN with a casino, but for me a college student it is set in such a way that it pays for me to go to a christian college. I understand that gambling is wrong, and that it can erode people lives, but then how do we as christians approach it?

  • Alan K

    I hate gambling, too, so I guess I’ll have to warm up to the idea of the Los Angeles Vikings. Yuck.

  • JR

    Gambling is a form of entertainment that needs to be done in moderation.