9/11: A Loss of Innocence?

Reflecting on the events of 9/11, one veteran journalist called the events of that day “a loss of innocence.”  According to the Oxford English Dictionary, the primary connotations of the word innocence (from the Latin, innocentia) are:

1. Freedom from sin, guilt, or moral wrong in general; the state of being untainted with, or unacquainted with, evil; moral purity.

2. Freedom from specific guilt; the fact of not being guilty of that with which one is charged; guiltlessness.

3. Freedom from cunning or artifice; guilelessness, artlessness, simplicity; hence, want of knowledge or sense, ignorance, silliness.

4. Of things: Harmlessness, innocuousness.

I assume she had in mind the second half of item one: “the state of being untainted with, or unacquainted with, evil.”  If that is so, then experience as a “veteran” journalist cannot count for much these days, because reporting, if nothing else, should acquaint us with evil.  And just a bit of sober self-exploration should vanquish the rest of whatever lack of acquaintance with evil we might claim.

What she meant, but probably would not have said (if she had thought about it) was that 9/11 signaled the end of naïveté — a state of denial that consists of a number of unnamed, indefensible assumptions:

  • There is no such thing as evil.
  • It can be reasoned away or “niced” away.
  • It cannot happen here.  It will not touch me.
  • I don’t need to be attentive to its presence.
  • I do not need to sacrifice my comfort (never mind my life) in opposing it.
  • And I cannot find it within.

Of course, these are not just indefensible assumptions.  They are dangerous and self-indulgent.  And it did not (or should not) have required a national tragedy to come to grips with the realization that they cannot possibly be true.  We owe it our parents and our children to be spiritually wiser and stronger than that.  And we owe it to those who died on that day to foreswear feeling sorry for ourselves — and to practice vigilance, both within and without.

The world did not change on 9/11.  It has always been this way.

"They didn't "leave by the millions"; they got bored and figured out that they could ..."

The Real Work of Bishops
"You've been wringing your hands over these things for 40 years; are you telling me ..."

The Real Work of Bishops
"A profound and provocative post that gets at the true heart of the sexual harassment ..."

Why the Conversation about Rights Won’t ..."

Browse Our Archives



What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment