Second Opinions and the Will of God

My brother is a surgeon and he understands the desire for second opinions.  When a procedure is complicated or the implications are far-reaching, it can be important to get another point of view.  If the second opinion confirms the first one you received, it’s also reassuring.  But when patients look for a third, fourth, or fifth opinion, he has also learned that his patients are probably looking for the opinion they want, not the opinion they need — or they don’t want to make a decision at all.

Similar problems arise in our search for the will of God.  The opinion of a friend can be an important resource in making a critical decision.  Those who know us can often see where and how God is moving in our lives more clearly than we can — especially if they love us, but they aren’t impressed with us.

But when the conversations drag on forever and the number of friends consulted begins to multiply, it is possible that we are looking for something that no one else can give us:

  • Certainty
  • Permission to choose
  • And absolution for the choices we have made

Our friends can’t choose for us.  The freedom to choose is God-given.  And the responsibility for our choices is ours.  We can’t find the will of God by taking a vote.


For more on the subject of finding and doing the will of God, see:

What God Wants for Your Life, Harper One, 1995.


"It is not an Episcopalian General Convention. It is a SJW convention. Main events include ..."

Should We Even Have a National ..."
"Well, I'm inclined to interpret those images dynamically, so I prefer the vocabulary from Ignatius ..."

Should We Even Have a National ..."
""If the culture is sold out to moral therapeutic deism," is a phrase to apologize ..."

4 Ways to Build Clergy Credibility
"Or we could adopt a modern perspective from management and think about bishops "empowering" congregations ..."

Should We Even Have a National ..."

Browse Our Archives

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment