I have a confession to make: sometimes I don’t go on the internet for days at a time. It’s because I write other things, and I have a life outside of the internet. So I largely missed the big controversy over Tom Swiss’ Straw Man article “There’s No Such Thing as Cultural Appropriation.” Erick DuPree wrote a great rebuttal, as did many, many, many, many others, and the argument continued. I stayed silent because I wasn’t sure I could say anything that hasn’t already been said; but in general I felt I should just “twinkle” at stuff I agreed with (most of the rebuttals) because I had nothing that wouldn’t just make more noise.
But I was talking to a nice young couple today who are getting married. I’m officiating the ceremony. She’s a Witch who is proud of her Norse and Celtic heritage; he’s a “spiritual-not-religious” young man of First Nations heritage. And she’s a reasonably new Witch, so she talks about a lot of the things newer Witches talk about, and one of those things was the stolen customs of Pagan peoples and faiths within the Christian overculture. And suddenly I realized I did have something important to offer.
Does it make you angry to listen to some Christians waxing rhetoric about “the reason for the season” when you know perfectly well that the reason that Christmas is on the 25th of December is because early Christians wanted to compete with the rival faith of the Sun God Mithras? Does it infuriate you when they go on and on about the life of Jesus Christ like it was completely original, utterly ignoring how the details were cribbed outright from Horus, Dionysus, Persephone, Osiris, Zoroaster, Krishna, the Buddha and Mithras? And on top of everything else, you know that pretty much every single modern Western Christmas custom was stolen from the Norse and the Saxons? (If it wasn’t invented by the Victorians).
Do you get angry at how the secular world is commercializing and trivializing Samhain? And now the Day of the Dead as well?
It makes me angry too. It makes me angry because the Christians of the past rewrote history. They stole whatever they wanted from the Pagans they shared the world with, even Pagan deities, even as they called them lesser beings, and raped them and tortured them and took them as slaves, and murdered them when they wouldn’t convert. The Burning Times are a myth, but the persecution of many Pagan cultures as some Christian cultures replaced them was not; and the prejudice and discrimination we suffer in modern times, born from centuries of lies and repression and deliberate ignorance, is all too real.
So YEAH, IT’S LIKE THAT. That’s what it feels like.
Update Oct. 6 – Made some changes due to a lack of clarity that I realized I had perpetuated when I read the comments. I am sorry; I did not mean to say that all Christians did these things. Also, I did not mean to say that my examples were cultural appropriation per se (though many of them were). However, I do feel that as a result of these examples, Pagans of all people should appreciate what cultural appropriation feels like, and should empathize with the feelings of others when they say that they are experiencing it. Adding this explanation to the end of my article somewhat diminishes my last line’s punchiness, but I see it is important since the misunderstanding is prevalent. Mea culpa!
Like Between the Shadows on Facebook and never miss a post!