In a world that increasingly defines identity through sexuality, personal struggles, and social movements, the question of who we truly are remains a point of deep reflection for many. For Daniel Maxwell, his journey from wrestling with same-sex attraction to fully surrendering to Christ illustrates the transformative power of the gospel and the sufficiency of Christ in shaping our ultimate identity. The Chorus in the Chaos Podcast recently sat down and discussed the topics of homosexuality and biblical Christianity with Daniel.
A Double Life: Wrestling with Faith and Identity
Daniel Maxwell, a worship pastor in South Carolina, grew up in a conservative Christian home where scripture was deeply instilled in him. Despite knowing the Bible well and memorizing scripture from a young age, Daniel found himself living a double-minded life. Outwardly, he presented himself as a faithful Christian, but inwardly, he harbored deep struggles with same-sex attraction, leading to a life of secrecy and internal conflict.
From as early as kindergarten, Daniel recognized that his attractions were different from his peers, but he had no language to describe it, nor did he feel safe discussing it within his church community. A pivotal moment occurred in junior high when he heard a Sunday school teacher make a harsh and condemning statement about homosexuality. The weight of this moment led him to isolate himself, believing he could never share his struggle without facing rejection.
As he entered high school and college, Daniel further embraced a lifestyle that conflicted with his faith, surrounding himself with a community that encouraged him to reconcile being both openly gay and a professing Christian. The tension between what he knew scripture taught and what culture affirmed created an ongoing internal battle that would ultimately lead him to a defining moment of surrender.
A Heart Transformed: Encountering the True Gospel
At the age of 20, everything changed. Alone in his room, Daniel had a moment of deep conviction as he read 1 Corinthians 6:9, which states that those who practice homosexuality, along with other sins, will not inherit the kingdom of God. However, it was the next verse—1 Corinthians 6:11—that truly opened his eyes: “And such were some of you. But you were washed, you were sanctified, you were justified in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ and by the Spirit of our God.”
It was in this moment that Daniel understood the weight of his sin, not just in terms of sexuality but in the broader context of unbelief. His struggle was not merely about attraction—it was about surrendering every part of his life to Christ. The gospel was not about making him straight; it was about making him new in Christ.
There was no altar call, no dramatic experience—just the quiet, powerful work of the Holy Spirit opening his eyes to the reality of his need for a Savior. From that point forward, Daniel resolved to follow Christ wholeheartedly, seeking holiness over personal gratification.
The Challenge of Walking in the Spirit
Despite his transformation, Daniel acknowledges that his same-sex attraction did not disappear overnight, nor has it completely left him to this day. However, his perspective on identity changed radically. He no longer identifies himself by his struggle but by his union with Christ. As Galatians 2:20 declares, “I have been crucified with Christ. It is no longer I who live, but Christ who lives in me.”
He emphasizes that the Christian walk is one of ongoing sanctification, not instant perfection. Through discipleship, intentional accountability, and deep immersion in scripture, he has learned to walk in the Spirit and deny the desires of the flesh. Instead of seeking a false sense of belonging in the LGBTQ+ community, he found authentic love and accountability within the church—brothers in Christ who care enough to get in his way and point him toward holiness.
Identity in Christ: Rejecting the ‘Gay Christian’ Label
One of the most controversial topics within Christian circles today is the idea of a “gay Christian.” Some argue that as long as a person remains celibate, it is acceptable to embrace that identity. Daniel firmly rejects this notion. Words matter, and as he points out, placing the adjective “gay” before “Christian” alters the fundamental nature of Christian identity. He argues that believers do not define themselves by their temptations—no one calls themselves an “adulterous Christian” or a “greedy Christian.” Instead, our identity must be rooted in Christ alone.
This debate was a major point of contention in the Revoice Conference and within denominations like the PCA, where some leaders advocated for the normalization of same-sex attraction within Christian identity. However, Daniel insists that the core issue is not sexuality, but rather unbelief. The gospel does not call us to simply suppress sinful desires; it calls us to be transformed entirely by the renewing of our minds (Romans 12:2).
A Call to the Church: Loving Well and Speaking Truth
For those who struggle with same-sex attraction and desire to follow Christ, Daniel urges them to immerse themselves in biblical community. The enemy thrives on isolation and discouragement, making accountability within the body of Christ essential. He warns against viewing marriage or heterosexuality as the ultimate goal, emphasizing that the true reward of the Christian life is Christ Himself.
For the church, Daniel calls for a balance of truth and love. Many in the LGBTQ+ community hesitate to leave because they fear loneliness more than anything else. The church must be a place that not only upholds biblical truth but also provides a tangible, loving community where people find belonging, support, and true fellowship in Christ.
Ultimately, Daniel’s story is not about becoming straight—it is about becoming holy. His testimony is a powerful reminder that our primary identity is not in our struggles, temptations, or cultural labels, but in the finished work of Christ.
As we navigate these conversations, may we remember Paul’s words in 1 Corinthians 6:11: “And such were some of you.” The church is not made up of perfect people, but of redeemed sinners walking in the grace and truth of Christ.
Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In