“The Church is Killing Its Gay Children” – The Deadly Results of Shame

“The Church is Killing Its Gay Children” – The Deadly Results of Shame March 2, 2023

Shame says, “There is something fundamentally wrong with you.” It is the lie at the very root of our identity. If I did something wrong, I can apologize and make amends. But if I am fundamentally wrong, what hope do I have?

Our greatest need is to be loved, to belong, to be accepted as we are. Shame says the exact opposite – that we do not fit in, are not acceptable as is and, fundamentally, are not lovable. Shame is the fundamental lie that keeps us separate, and it wreaks havoc in self-hatred and self-rejection.

Jesus never shamed anyone, and he never shames us. The truth is, Jesus is very different from the non-affirming Christian church.

Neither does he give us permission to shame each other. Brene Brown has done paradigm-shifting work on shame, and one particular finding about men and shame is earth-shattering. “When looking at the traits associated with masculinity in the US, the researchers identified the following: winning, emotional control, risk-taking, violence, dominance, playboy, self-reliance, primacy of work, power over women, disdain for homosexuality, and pursuit of status. Understanding these lists and what they mean is critically important to understanding shame…” says Brene Brown.

Isn’t that a shock? “For men,” Brown says, “there’s a cultural message that promotes homophobic cruelty. If you want to be masculine in our culture, it’s not enough to be straight – you must also show an outward disgust for the gay community.”

Shame has been foisted into various groups throughout history. Minority ethnic groups. Women. Children. LGBTQ. Especially vulnerable today in our highly aggressive culture are teenagers, and parents have a keen responsibility to protect their children from shame, to counter the shame they will face from the outside world, and to help them refrain from inflicting shame themselves.

Our LGBTQ+ children are in crisis. Depression, self-harm, substance abuse, suicide are the fruits of faith-based family rejection. 40% of all homeless youth are LGBTQ+. 57% of transgender youth without supportive parents attempt suicide. When even one parent is supportive, that number drops to 4%.

The non-affirming church has used shame and condemnation, justified by twisted Scripture and false teaching, to drive these kids out of their homes, out of their churches, and to the streets.

As Kimberly Knight said, “The church is killing its gay children.”

It is indefensible.

And if you claim to follow Jesus this should stop you in your tracks, drive you to your knees, and cause you to open your heart, cry out, and listen for the Spirit of God.

Home needs to be a sanctuary for our LGBTQ+ kids. Teens are the most vulnerable, not only from their own often unexpected self-discoveries, but from the learned disdain for homosexuality they face day after day.

Parents cannot always ward off the disdain from without, but they can provide an oasis of life and belonging that makes a world of difference. However unsure you may be about aspects of this issue, your task of offering support and safety to your teen is undeniable.

As shocked as some parents may be to hear their child is gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgender, queer or questioning, it is important to take care that your reaction never communicates shame, on your part or theirs. It heaps piles of shame on an already challenging situation.  And it does something Jesus would never do and never told us to do.  Again, Jesus is so unlike the non-affirming Christian church who claims to follow him.

As a trained theologian and an ordained pastor, I believe that the Bible does NOT condemn same-sex relationships. But if you do still believe homosexuality is a sin, I have a question for you: Do you trust God?

If you trust God, then you can just love your child and let God handle what you don’t understand?

And think about it… if God does not change your child, why would we think we can or should?

Maybe that is just how God created them… wonderfully, beautifully, imperfectly perfect. Beloved.

Just like you and me.

We have comprehensive resources and vibrant supportive community — for parents and for LGBTQ+. Just come say hello at www.FreedHearts.org

"Preaching the gospel (John 3:16) to them is the loving approach, and just let God ..."

What is a Christian to do ..."
"love them, and hold up God's Law, and when they look in that mirror, they ..."

What is a Christian to do ..."
"I watched the Dante series on PBS a while back, and as always, I was ..."

Has the Church Resealed the Tomb?
"You don't help your case by casting "law" as a pejorative. Anti-Judaism is not what ..."

Has the Church Resealed the Tomb?

Browse Our Archives