Math findings & a big fallacy

Math findings & a big fallacy March 14, 2008

A blue-ribbon presidential panel charged with figuring out what has gone wrong with math education in this country. Here is a summary of the findings. They include this observation:

Children badly need both automatic recall of math facts and understanding of big concepts, in effect declawing both sides in the decades-long “math wars.”

This points to a fallacy that seems everywhere in education and elsewhere: the FALSE DICHOTOMY. How would anyone think there needs to be a CHOICE between EITHER knowing material OR understanding it? To be educated about any subject you need BOTH! You also need to be able to apply it yourself.

(Note that the whole range of what education must be is fulfilled in the paradigm of classical education: grammar [knowing]; logic [understanding]; rhetoric [personal application].)

What are some other false dichotomies? (I’ll get you started: faith & works; orthodoxy & mission. . . .)

"Coming from the ELCA (confirmed in LCA) and now in the LCMS, I can confirm ..."

Monday Miscellany, 5/13/24
"In the LCMS we were really blessed with a (I'll just call them) mainline protestant* ..."

Monday Miscellany, 5/13/24
"That has been the dilemma of US politics since we were young, hasn't it? When ..."

Monday Miscellany, 5/13/24
"The left going after liberals more than conservatives is nothing new. In the late 60s, ..."

Monday Miscellany, 5/13/24

Browse Our Archives