Would universal health care lower the abortion rate?

Would universal health care lower the abortion rate? March 15, 2010

Catholic journalist T. J. Reid makes a challenging connection for us pro-lifers:

Increasing health-care coverage is one of the most powerful tools for reducing the number of abortions — a fact proved by years of experience in other industrialized nations. All the other advanced, free-market democracies provide health-care coverage for everybody. And all of them have lower rates of abortion than does the United States.

This is not a coincidence. There’s a direct connection between greater health coverage and lower abortion rates. To oppose expanded coverage in the name of restricting abortion gets things exactly backward. It’s like saying you won’t fix the broken furnace in a schoolhouse because you're against pneumonia. Nonsense! Fixing the furnace will reduce the rate of pneumonia. In the same way, expanding health-care coverage will reduce the rate of abortion.

At least, that’s the lesson from every other rich democracy.

The latest United Nations comparative statistics, available at http://data.un.org, demonstrate the point clearly. The U.N. data measure the number of abortions for women ages 15 to 44. They show that Canada, for example, has 15.2 abortions per 1,000 women; Denmark, 14.3; Germany, 7.8; Japan, 12.3; Britain, 17.0; and the United States, 20.8. When it comes to abortion rates in the developed world, we’re No. 1.

No one could argue that Germans, Japanese, Brits or Canadians have more respect for life or deeper religious convictions than Americans do. So why do they have fewer abortions?

One key reason seems to be that all those countries provide health care for everybody at a reasonable cost. That has a profound effect on women contemplating what to do about an unwanted pregnancy.

via T.R. Reid – Universal health care tends to cut the abortion rate – washingtonpost.com.

How would you answer this?   If you don’t accept this explanation, how would you account for the USA having the highest abortion rate?   If the connection the author posits is real, shouldn’t pro-lifers support some version of universal health care, even it means sacrificing some of our lesser principles?

UPDATE: Michael New answers the article.

"I may have shared this here before, but it's worth sharing again. An insightful and ..."

Something Americans Can Agree On: Hating ..."
"I saw snow in Houston once. Some of it even made it all the way ..."

Something Americans Can Agree On: Hating ..."
"You're clearly more interested in repeating this claim than substantiating it, so I'll give you ..."

The Mindset that Produced Slavery
"And right wingers think a right winger writing a book about a mindset he has ..."

The Mindset that Produced Slavery

Browse Our Archives