Huckabee’s pardons

Huckabee’s pardons

Former presidential candidate Mike Huckabee is a different kind of Christian conservative. Instead of coming across as just another right wing spear carrier for the Republican party, he brought to the table something that Christians in politics seemed to have been strangely lacking; namely, a sense of compassion. Also wit. As he told Leno, he reminded people of someone they worked with, rather than the guy who laid them off (an allusion to rival Mitt Romney). Huckabee is not above using government to help the little guy.

As governor of Arkansas, Huckabee’s compassion led him to grant clemency to quite a few prisoners. Now one of them, Maurice Clemmons, has killed four police officers. (To be fair, his granting the parole didn’t lead directly to the new crimes. The parolee got thrown in jail again in another state, whereupon he was again set free.)

The pioneering Christian blogger Joe Carter, who now blogs for First Things, served on Huckabee’s staff during his presidential campaign. He thinks highly of Governor Huckabee but reports that he applied his Christian faith in such a way that he did show mercy to criminals, especially if they reported a conversion, were recommended by a pastor, or made up for their crime through “restorative justice.” But Joe thinks he was sometimes naive in doing so.

Loyal reader of this blog Eric Richey proposed that we discuss this in light of the doctrine of vocation, that Huckabee–who is also an ordained Baptist minister–might have been confusing his calling as a minister of the gospel with his calling as the governor of the state. Put another way, is this a violation of the doctrine of the Two Kingdoms, confusing the Christian’s individual spiritual mandate to forgive, with the magistrate’s Romans 13 duty to punish evildoers?

And yet, earthly rulers are to temper justice with mercy sometimes, aren’t they? His powers as governor gave him the power to pardon and to commute sentences. Is it fair to hold him responsible for this tragic outcome, which he certainly didn’t intend? Should this disqualify him for the office of president, should he decide to run again?

"If you're sick of Trump and MAGA being brought up here, think of how sick ..."

The Collapse of Our Knowledge System
"I see Gioia as taking notice of a significant problem, but I'm not buying his ..."

The Collapse of Our Knowledge System
"My comment here is confusing: "In addition the way that people talk about "COVID" as ..."

The Collapse of Our Knowledge System
"I have a lot to say on this topic.Sort of directly related to multiple aspects ..."

The Collapse of Our Knowledge System

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!