DISCUSS: Peace & Prosperity or Freedom & Democracy?

DISCUSS: Peace & Prosperity or Freedom & Democracy?

The “Bush Doctrine” from President George W. Bush made as a priority for United States foreign policy, especially in the Middle East, to spread freedom and democracy.

The “Trump Doctrine,” as articulated by the president in his recent visit to Qatar and Saudi Arabia is to promote peace and prosperity.

The Bush Doctrine had nobler ideals, but it resulted in the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, both of which failed to implement freedom and democracy, which turned out to be not universal aspirations but the products of a culture and a religion that were alien to those nations.

The Trump Doctrine sounds more crass.  He held audiences with terrorists and supporters of terrorists, monarchs and dictators, promising them major trade advantages in return for peace.  But by holding out the possibility that both sides would profit from a U.S. trade deal, he made peace between India and Pakistan.

Rich Lowry discusses these two foreign policy philosophies in his essay Introducing the Trump Doctrine.

My questions for your input and discussion:  Is peace and prosperity the best we can realistically accomplish in foreign policy?  Or should we be promoting such values as freedom, democracy, and human rights?

Can we have both, or would we still need to prioritize one or the other?  In terms of the Trump Doctrine, is there any reason the U.S. and China should be antagonistic?

 

"What would you have considered a "helpful response" to the sexual revolution? Not that I ..."

The Pope Takes On AI: A ..."
"I myself am skeptical of both the promise and the peril of AI, but perhaps ..."

The Pope Takes On AI: A ..."
"What I am saying is the church can tell me what I can or cannot ..."

The Pope Takes On AI: A ..."
""Politicians who do not toe the dogma line in terms of barring certain sinful behaviors ..."

The Pope Takes On AI: A ..."

Browse Our Archives