Confession of Honest Rage
I took some heat from the anti-death penalty crowd for saying those words at a press conference in Mississippi last week. Mr. Crawford is scheduled to be executed this Wednesday, October 15 for the 1993 rape and murder of Kristy Ray. But the truth of what I said stands. I’d say it again without apology.
The rage that rises in a parent at the sight of monstrous harm to their child is real. It’s raw. It’s human. I know that impulse. I won’t hide it behind pious language or false purity.
Grief and the Refusal of Retaliation
Yet, I refuse to let grief harden into a doctrine of sanctioned reprisal. I’ve knelt across from those condemned. I’ve held hands with families consumed by sorrow. I’ve seen the faces of those who were taught cruelty and the faces of those who were taught mercy. From that place I declare this truth…the executioner’s actions cannot reclaim what was lost, cannot heal the terror of a violated life and cannot restore the dignity of a stolen childhood. It can only add another grave to the ledger of human harm. Our calling is justice beyond killing.
The Crossroads of Law and Ethos
We stand at a crossroads where law and ethos meet. When the state chooses to execute it teaches with unmistakable clarity that violence is an acceptable means to end violence. What are we teaching our children, our neighbors, our neighbors’ children when we make killing a civic ritual? We’re spelling out an ethic that answers harm with annihilation. And that ethic doesn’t stop at the prison gates…it seeps into homes, schools and streets. I oppose executions not out of naïveté but out of moral urgency. I oppose them because they replicate the very evil we claim to abhor. The way forward must be justice beyond killing.
The Hard Work of Mercy – Justice Beyond Killing
The prophetic tradition calls us to higher things…to mercy, to grace, to compassion…not as sentimentality but as the hard work of forming a people. These aren’t soft virtues. They’re disciplines of the soul. Mercy requires courage…the courage to resist the easy headline, the instant retribution, the loud demand for spectacle. Mercy requires institutions that can hold pain without answering it with death. Compassion demands a public structure that invests in survivors, funds truth and stages accountability in ways that don’t end in irreversible erasure. This is what it means to build justice beyond killing.
Justice Beyond Killing
Make no mistake…acknowledging the call to mercy doesn’t diminish the reality of monstrous crimes. It doesn’t turn away from justice. Justice is demanded…by victims, by communities and by our own moral consciences. But justice isn’t identical to killing. Retribution might satisfy a hunger for payback but it doesn’t teach repentance. It doesn’t create repair. It doesn’t offer moral education. A society that answers murder with more killing flattens the moral imagination until only one recourse is visible…the termination of persons rather than the transformation of lives. We must restore our moral vision around justice beyond killing.
A Call to Moral Leadership
I call on anyone who still has a conscience to recognize the spiritual violence inherent in state executions. I call on religious leaders to join me and preach a counter-narrative…one that refuses to sacralize vengeance. I call on parents to ask themselves what kind of moral legacy they want to leave. Do we want to hand our children a creed that tells them some lives may be ended as an antidote to harm? Or will we teach them that human worth is guarded even when human failure is punished? Our civic choices are also moral lessons. Those choices must lead us toward justice beyond killing.
Alternatives that Honor Life – Justice Beyond Killing
There are concrete alternatives that honor both the pain of victims and the sanctity of life. Life without parole prevents further violence while preserving the chance for truth to be told, for remorse to be voiced, for restitution to be made in humanly meaningful ways. Restorative pathways place victims and communities at the center demanding that offenders face the consequences of their actions…not as spectacle but as encounter, naming harm and seeking reparation. These aren’t platitudes. They’re real designs meant to break cycles of pain instead of widening them. They’re the groundwork for justice beyond killing.
Breaking the Habits that Destroy Us
If you tell me that some crimes are so horrific that the desire for death is inevitable I won’t deny the feeling. But we have to decide whether inevitability is a law of nature or a habit of the heart. The prophetic task is to break the habits that destroy us…to call forth a people who live by principles stronger than expedience and louder than the drumbeat of vengeance. That’s the prophetic demand—to become a people of justice beyond killing.
Stop Killing People
So I declare plainly and urgently…stop killing people. Not because I’m ignorant of pain but because I’ve seen what killing does to the souls of the living. Not because I long for impunity but because I long for justice that doesn’t betray the very humanity it claims to defend. Don’t mistake this for indifference. I grieve with families whose lives have been torn apart. I join their demand for truth, accountability and protection. But I won’t join in perpetuating the same violence that birthed their grief. If we’re to be a people who rise above the logic of retaliation then we must refuse to make killing the currency of justice. This is my prophetic plea…let us choose another way…one that honors victims, restrains offenders and builds a future where mercy isn’t an afterthought but the law of our common life.
*
*If you would like to support the Execution Intervention Project (the organization that financially supports Dr. Hood’s work), click here.
Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In