Never Alone 5

Never Alone 5 July 21, 2009

Shelves, by the way, do make a difference. If my books had made me famous or wealthy (I’d prefer the latter over the former), and if publishers thought of me as someone worth marketing lavishly (which they don’t), I would have a library of books housed caringly in Levenger bookcases (which I don’t have). You know the kind: stackable, individual shelves, each with a glass door engraved (“History: Ancient,” or “Essayists: American”), and made of solid, honest-to-goodness oak. They would surround my room, some four feet high, some five, and some eight or nine. Above the four feet high shelves would be art work from the finest – “finest” for me means Rembrandt and Carravagio, not Picasso or any of the modernists who, like fiction writers, make up their own world. I’ve got but one bookshelf like this and it is what the Germans call a billige Nachahmung. It is about five feet high, stands proudly in our living room on a wooden floor, and presents our set of Dickens, some of the Great Books of the Western World, some of Bonhoeffer in German, some baseball books, and a half shelf of my own (paperback) books. On it sits pictures of our two children, and behind them a nice clock (always, as my wife insists, set about 7-10 minutes ahead).

If shelves matter, so does having one’s own library and a few handsome sets of books. Thoughtful people don’t have “offices.” They have either “studies” or “libraries.” Offices are for the business people who make chairs that annoy readers, while studies and libraries are for the sort of people who use sesquipedalians and avoid the riff-raff at Barnes & Noble. Studies are for studying, but libraries, like the great library at Alexandria, are for readers and browsers. I do both in my library, where I am proud that I have a few sets. I prefer to keep my sets together. So, Dickens’ novels sit together (as a family ought to) in my living room. Come to think of it, our living room is also a place where the family tells its stories, so Dickens is good company. I own the Great Books of the Western World. Robert Maynard Hutchins wrote volume one and it is a good (not a great) book called The Great Conversation: The Substance of a Liberal Education. I value the Syntopicon volumes (#s 2-3) because they at times put me in touch with a wealth of references to check on a give topic – a topic organized by a Thomistic mind (Mortimer Adler). It was that same Thomistic mind that (over) categorized Encyclopaedia Brittanica into a Graecized trinity: Micropaedia, Macropaedia, and Propaedia (with two volumes of indices). I have this set, too. On my shelves sit about 60 volumes of the Loeb Classical Library. They are advertised as handsome; they are. Just as handsome are volumes in A.A. Knopf’s Everyman’s Library, and I have fallen to the allure of their volumes instead even of more readable translations – I found it impossible to read anything other than Fitzgerald’s translation of The Iliad because I liked the feel of the publisher’s clothbound book. Other sets stand together in my library, but mostly they belong to my library wearing the study cap, sets on Hebrew words, biblical books, and ancient Jewish history.

Libraries, as Lionel Casson has shown, also have a history, from the early library in Assyria of Ashurbanipal to the great collection of Aristotle to the repository of reliable manuscripts in Alexandria. Aristophanes is perhaps one of the only examples of a library director who had as his mission to read all the books in the Library at Alexandria, but it was Callimachus of Cyrene who first thought up the good idea of a catalogue (called the Pinakes) to a library so the stacks could be used efficiently. If the most frequently stolen books today are (get this!) The Holy Bible and (a close second) The Joy of Sex, it should not be forgotten that the great library at Pergamum was not only on the top of a hill next to the Temple of Athena, but it was a collection of (largely) stolen books. That library became the focus of several warlords who saw its stolen books as potential booty for their library (of stolen books). (How about you? Any stolen books in your collection? Return to lender, to clean and jerk a line from Elvis.) Books were not just stolen in those days; they were read. In fact, Plutarch, the master of anecdotes, tells a story of Lucullus, a Roman who had the good fortune of a good library: other readers would come to his library “as if to a reception hall of the Muses, and pass whole days together, happily staying away from their other duties.” Robert Benchley, that wit of New York, once said, “anyone can do any amount of work, provided it isn’t the work he is supposed to be doing at that moment.” There’s a man with insight; and he speaks of what (in the estimation of my administration) as I contemplate reading Al Gini’s The Importance of Being Lazy, with its legitimating subtitle: In Praise of Play, Leisure and Vacations in my two-roomed library.

Libraries became mirror-shaped in Rome. Why? The Romans’ constant worry about the superiority of the ancient Greeks and their culture led them to read both Latin greats and the Greek greats, and that led to their “twin libraries”. That is, with a statue to some emperor or god in the middle, that statue was flanked on either side by a Greek library and a Latin library. (One must wonder what Freud or Rohrschach would make of such architecture. I’ve got an idea what both might say.) Such libraries, naturally, had sets of both Cicero and Plato. Nero, who never fell short of being a jerk, annexed his twin libraries with Roman baths – to provide not only mental but also physical pleasure. And here we have the beginnings of student distractions: will, they ask nightly, I go to the library or to the recreation center? What libraries, especially those in Rome, tell us remains vital for the desultory reader: we must move from our world (Latin) into the world of the other (Greek) if we want to comprehend this ever interesting and perplexing organism we call “human”. To do this, we must read widely and that means not only the Greeks and Latins and Hebrews and Egyptians, but find the sets of great authors throughout the entire world.

"The "to what degree" question has been pretty well answered by this point. Don't hold ..."

Climate Change Deniers? (RJS)
"Lying is not illegal, except under oath or where extracting money from someone. "Equivocation" is ..."

Non-Disparagement Agreements And Truth-Telling In The ..."
"What is our responsibility regarding the environment? To treat it as God's property, I suppose. ..."

Climate Change Deniers? (RJS)
"I would agree with the a) b) c) solution. The main battle for me is ..."

Climate Change Deniers? (RJS)

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Bob Smallman

    “Any stolen books in your collection?”
    None that I know of. But I’ve lost quite a few of my own books. I love to loan them out and have never bothered to develop a check-out system; and (occasionally) folks will forget to return them — a fact I only notice months or years later when I can’t find some volume I’m looking for. And, of course, by then I’ve forgotten who borrowed it. My favorite story along these lines is the family who were moving away to Cleveland and while they were cleaning out their books donated several to our church library. And there, among those donated books, was an out-of-print Walt Kaiser book that I’d been missing for years!

  • We are a not-for-profit educational organization, founded by Mortimer Adler and we have recently made an exciting discovery–three years after writing the wonderfully expanded third edition of How to Read a Book, Mortimer Adler and Charles Van Doren made a series of thirteen 14-minute videos, lively discussing the art of reading. The videos were produced by Encyclopaedia Britannica. For reasons unknown, sometime after their original publication, these videos were lost.
    Three hours with Mortimer Adler on one DVD. A must for libraries and classroom teaching the art of reading.
    I cannot over exaggerate how instructive these programs are–we are so sure that you will agree, if you are not completely satisfied, we will refund your donation.
    Please go here to see a clip and learn more:

  • No stolen books in our library. However, we often have clients who “borrow” and then forget to return them. As long as the books are doing good for someone we don’t mind.
    Our clients are victims of domestic violence and juvenile offenders (aka more victims of domestic violence). Our library shelves are filled with titles to inspire, motivate, educate or encourage. Few people need encouragement more than the people we work with. It’s a treat for us to be able to offer the books.
    Now, if there were only more bookcases!
    Thanks for your enjoyable article. Please keep them coming!

  • I used to put a lot of time into my books and the shelves that contained them. My most important possessions. And worthy to be displayed.
    I was the guy who asked Jesus what I needed to do to serve Him, was told, “Give away all your books and join me,” and shuffled away heartbroken.
    I so wanted to share them with others but would get so proctologist prone about their return that I finally (for my wife’s sanity as well as for my health) had to take on another approach. I now have a set of special bookcases (the German’s refer to them as “Fallenhover Hoften” shelves) that threaten to bury any passerby who does not tread lightly.
    As a result, I am forced to give away any books that would add weight to my collection. I am even more motivated by the fact that mi esposa has lined the wall right next to my side of the bed with those treasures.
    But the more I give away, the deeper I sleep at night.

  • Mike M

    Scot: this statement “If my books had made me famous or wealthy (I’d prefer the latter over the former)” is one of the funniest things I have ever seen you write. And who says theologians have no sense of humor?
    As for “some baseball books”? How many do you have? Here’s my list:
    • “Baseball is a Funny Game” by Joe Garagiola
    • “I Never Had It Made: An Autobiography of Jackie Robinson” by Jackie Robinson
    • “Mr. Cub” by Ernie Banks and Jim Enright
    • “Moonlight Graham” by Terence Mann
    • “When You Come to a Fork in the Road, Take It!: Inspiration and Wisdom From One of Baseball’s Greatest Heroes” by Yogi Berra and Dave Kaplan
    What’s in YOUR collection?

  • Scot,
    What a wonderful and insightful post. I have loved to read and loved books for many years. I appreciate getting to know the books that have made such a difference in your life as reflected by what is on your shelves.
    The paragraphs regarding the history of libraries were very interesting. This gives me more of an appreciation for the work and contribution of libraries in our history and culture.
    On another note– I believe that a subtle shift took place when ministers no longer had a “study” but an “office.” A friend of mine in the Dallas-Fort Worth area had, for many years, an office at the church building where he would counsel, meet with others, etc. In an adjoining room was his study.

  • Karen Granger

    Hi Scot,
    As former Director of Public Relations for Levenger and the spokesmodel champion of your book, “The Real Mary,” I was thrilled to read your post. I’m a writer and speaker and have done many women’s events quoting from your book. I’ve read it about 3 times and highlighted every other sentance it seems…a great work!
    Also, I love how you refer to “study” and or “home library”…my brother-in-law Steve Leveen, owner and founder of Levenger will enjoy this. Check out his book “The Little Guide to Your Well Read Life.”
    I just had the opportunity to meet w/ Eugene Peterson (The Message) this summer at his home. He said, “Come upstairs and see my “study”…I thought I’d just about died and gone to heaven surrounded by all the great works and his genious.
    We also met w/ his son (in another state) and he said, “I’ll be in my study…” I think I’ll change my office into a study, so I can be one of the smart guys:)
    Anyway, happy to connect w/ you!
    Your fan and fan club president for Mary (and Levenger book cases!)
    Karen Granger

  • I absolutely love glimpses into people’s personal “studies/libraries.” Are you willing to post a photo of your personal study? Come on, don’t be shy. Here’s my modest yet cozy book-nook: