Liberal Arts at Starfleet Academy

Liberal Arts at Starfleet Academy January 4, 2019

Lately there has been an incredible amount of discussion about the liberal arts, liberal education, small majors, the humanities, and countless other aspects of education. I kept noting links to articles that I thought were worth sharing, but it took being reminded of the clip below from Star Trek: The Next Generation to prompt me into action. No less an authority than Capt. Picard himself speaks here about the value of being liberally educated!

Michael Roth writes:

[I]n a world scarred by violence, instigated polarization and managed parochialism, these educational practices of consideration, critique and empathy are beacons of hope. Seeing the world from someone else’s point of view is no simple task, but you get much better at it when you practice. That’s what we are doing much of the time on our campuses.

When we foster intellectual diversity, we are practicing learning from others different from ourselves. Sure, sometimes people retreat to the “bubbles” of their own tribe, whether they call that safety, tradition or prejudice. But much of the time, our teachers, students and staff encounter difference and try to figure out how to learn from it, sometimes finding out that commonalities are more significant than the distinctions that first impressed them.

Such encounters are woven into the fabric of our everyday educational practices. These days, they are hopeful alternatives to the normalization of violence and the pollution of our public sphere. Now, more than ever, we must work to protect them.

Much of the discussion relates to the practical workplace value of certain majors and certain courses, or of the liberal arts in general. But it is important to reflect on big questions, at least why one is pursuing one’s professional path if not much bigger questions than that. The crucial point, which Picard speaks to, is that it is not an either/or question. Study of philosophy, religion, ethics, art, and so on all enhance one’s capacity to do more than simply deal with mechanical aspects of piloting a spacecraft. It is important to be prepared to utilize those piloting skills to save lives, for instance. If one is an engineer without thinking about ethics, one can do significant harm. Plus, if one hasn’t learned how to learn, then when shuttlecraft pilot suddenly becomes a job, many will find it hard if not impossible to adapt. Being able to fact-check will be increasingly relevant in every career, but also for citizenship, as will simply being able to identify what kind of source one has found and what it should or should not be used for. Being aware of the limits of our reasoning abilities is a key to using such skills wisely and appropriately. Appreciating the value of as well as the differences between the humanities and sciences seems to be of ongoing crucial importance.

See also:

Knowing How To Know

Sciences and Humanities: Moving on from the ‘Two Cultures’

Measuring the Evolution Gap between the Humanities and the Sciences

Why postmodernism and science can’t stand each other

Making a liberal arts education relevant again

Victor Weisskopf and the joy of scientific insight

Employers want English majors more than business majors

How the liberal arts prepared one grad for medicine

Student attitudes to free speech, and the need to preserve intellectual diversity and free inquiry in higher ed, were also popular topics in recent months.

Inside Higher Ed featured a piece on the need to teach students that certain things are true. They also featured three different articles responding to the suggestion that it is time to get rid of college majorsThe Connection also contributed to the conversation.

Illustrations from trucker shortages and an expensive restaurant for higher education.

 

 

"“I'm sorry to cause you pain.”As with Paul, it’s only sarcastic pain :-)Perhaps, more amusement!"

Easter and Historical Nuance
"I'm sorry to cause you pain.I think that a big problem with Paul's letters in ..."

Easter and Historical Nuance
"Since my head is hurting reading Vinny and John’s comments, I’d like to get their ..."

Easter and Historical Nuance
"I didn't make any suggestion. I was simply explaining what I understand Carrier's position to ..."

Easter and Historical Nuance

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


TRENDING AT PATHEOS Progressive Christian
What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Marta L

    My one real qualm with how Star Trek (and Picard in particular) handle the humanities is, they don’t really portray it as something you have to work at. I mean, his background is so broad: he quotes Shakespeare readily, converses with Data about classical music, gives Wesley a philosophy text in that clip above — in addition to his first career as an archaeologist, his trying to prove Fermat’s theorem in his spare time, and his understanding enough physics to devise the Picard Maneuver.

    Obviously that allows for a really enriched show, but it also gives the impression that this really can be done, all while captaining a starship besides. Maybe this is my particular academic background in philosophy of religion showing: too much exposure to people who read an apologetics manual’s two-paragraph gloss of the cosmological argument and think there’s nothing more to be gained from thinking about Aristotle, Al-Ghazali, Leibniz, and Koons, I suppose. I’m not sure how you could do better given the structure of the show. Still, it always struck me as a flaw. (Maybe a minor one, though — it really is a thinking person’s show!)