This two-hour documentary, written and directed by Michelle Ferrari, tells the largely unknown story of America’s quest to breed healthy babies – the impulse to perfect humanity – through eugenics beginning in the late 19th century. By the mid 1920’s eugenics was mainstream and codified by laws that restricted immigration and allowed for the sterilization of tens of thousands of American citizens deemed to be “morons,” “unfit,” or poor, illiterate, had a child due to rape, or a prostitute.
As the film narrates, in Buck v Bell, the U.S. Supreme Court upheld a Virginia statute in 1927 that permitted the forced (without consent) sterilization of those deemed unfit and a burden to society if they procreated. It was a “fake” case actually; the attorney representing Carrie Buck was hired by and took orders from attorneys the Virginia State Colony for Epileptics and the Feebleminded. This institution created this test case to insure they could continue to carry out their policies and procedures to purify populations. This decision by the Supreme Court has never been overturned and still stands. In fact, forced sterilization is permitted in half the states in America by laws that have not been challenged or overturned. (See my review of the 2016 documentary about the sterilization of Latino women in Los Angeles, No Mas Bebes.)Eugenics (“well” “born”) was coined by a cousin of Charles Darwin in 1883, Sir Francis Dalton. His vision was by using genetic statistics humans could take charge of their own evolution. He based his ideas on the work of the priest-scientist Gregor Mendel’s who is considered the father of genetics through his work on generational inheritance of traits passed down through pea plants.
But it was the American Harvard-educated biologist Charles Davenport who established eugenics in the United States. He believed that not only physical traits could be passed down but also criminality, pauperism and sexual deviance, could as well. He held that new immigrants were diluting white American stock and convinced the Carnegie Foundation to fund his work which, among other things, led to laws that based on faulty science, defined who was unfit, allowed forced sterilizations and regulated immigration to northern European countries and limited those from southern Europe. Though the faulty work of eugenics lasted less than 40 years (discredited during the Depression when even the rich became paupers), American eugenics influenced Hitler and the Nazis and its legacy is with us still.
“The Eugenics Crusade” tells a chilling story and shows how easy it is to use fear of “the other” to lead to the most inhumane treatment of human beings.