Paprocki vs. the Pope, on ’emotional … anecdotal stories’

Paprocki vs. the Pope, on ’emotional … anecdotal stories’

Sonja at WIT shares a bit of Pope Francis’ homily from Wednesday. It strikes me as saying rather the opposite of what Bishop Paprocki had to say in the same-sex marriage forum we talked about yesterday.

Thomas Paprocki, bishop of Springfield, Ill., last Friday:

Paprocki said [Sr. Jeannnine] Gramick presented her case from an emotional position while he said the church’s stance comes from the position of faith and reason.

“My position is not a question of anecdotal stories,” he said.

Francis, bishop of Rome, June 5, 2013:

The Sadducees were talking about this woman as if she were a laboratory, all aseptic – hers was an [abstract] moral [problem]. When we think of the people who suffer so much, do we think of them as though they were an [abstract moral conundrum], pure ideas, “but in this case … this case …,” or do we think about them with our hearts, with our flesh, too? I do not like it when people speak about tough situations in an academic and not a human manner, sometimes with statistics … and that’s it. In the Church there are many people in this situation.

See earlier: “Thou shalt not treat human beings as ‘controversial issues’

 


Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


TAKE THE
Religious Wisdom Quiz

What city is considered holy by Christians, Jews, and Muslims alike?

Select your answer to see how you score.