10 Years Ago, I Embraced Nonviolence & Anabaptism

10 Years Ago, I Embraced Nonviolence & Anabaptism July 25, 2018

In the past month or so, I’ve been interviewed on two different podcasts.

  • ​​Bros, Bible’s, & Beer: This was fun. Three great guys who talk about faith from three different angles. One is closer to where I’d be at when it comes to theology. Another is more in the conservative-evangelical realm. And the third one is deeply practical. So good! We need more spaces online where differing perspectives can disagree in love.
  • Laity Podcast (iTunes version): This was also quite fun. These two guys come from a Church of Christ background and have done some de/reconstruction and are now using a podcast as a means to promote helpful conversation from within that tradition (and beyond). In this interview, they ask me about what I’m up to, etc. But then, it is all about Anabaptism and the kingdom of God.

​​Since listening to my interview on the Laity Podcast, a thought came to mind: it has been ten years–this summer–since I embraced Christian nonviolence and my anabaptist roots. Ten years.​ And I can’t imagine my life with God without this shift.

For those of you who don’t know, Anabaptism is a tradition from the time of the Reformation (1500s–) that emphasized the centrality of Jesus and following him by taking up the Sermon on the Mount as our marching orders. Several ideas come out of this stream of the faith, such as an emphasis on believers baptism (being baptized as an infant in the 1500s usually was tied to citizenship to a secular nation [although claiming to be Christian], which the Anabaptists strongly protested against), nonviolence, the priesthood of all Christians, and God’s kingdom as expressed through a contrast-community to dominant culture.

It took a long time to finally be convinced of nonviolence, mostly because of the narratives I was given about the need to defend against and fight off evil. It wasn’t until the summer of 2008 that I opened myself up to allowing the New Testament to change my mind. A few years back I shared the full story. Here’s a quote:

Then, I started reading books in college that hinted toward Anabaptist convictions, naming them in a positive light. By the time I entered Fresno Pacific Biblical Seminary in 2007, I was already convinced that I could never join the military because I couldn’t trust an earthly authority to command me to kill – but I was still no pacifist. The biblical text seemed to point toward nonviolence but it all seemed too irrational to me: Jesus couldn’t have possibly meant that!

The summer following my first year of seminary a tour bus powered by used cooking grease showed up in Fresno. Two guys, Shane Claiborne and Chris Haw jumped out and gave a presentation about their book Jesus for President. The passion with which they spoke and the articulate biblical arguments they presented finally convinced me to let go of my fears and embrace nonviolence as normative for Christian discipleship.

In fact, on that night, I sensed the Spirit inviting me to be convinced. It was a catalytic moment in my journey that I’m grateful for.


Virtue…

What hasn’t happened yet, is the testing of my view on violence. For this I’m grateful as well.

One of the most important things that I’ve learned in this past decade is that peace is a virtue that Jesus wants to cultivate in us. Early on, I was tempted to believe that the ‘ethics’ or outward expressions of peace and justice were what mattered more than personal piety. Like many people who learn something new or go through a paradigm shift, my pendulum swing was drastic because the gravity of the shift felt so massive.

What I came to notice, however, was that my personal experience with Jesus couldn’t be divorced from my ‘radical’ commitment to the peaceable kingdom of God. Peace, as a virtue, means that I can learn the posture of peace inwardly through growing with Jesus. Then, if the moment ever does come that my theology is tested, my default will hopefully be to see an enemy as someone to love rather than to fight.

That is the hardest part, after all, about all theology: living it out.



<<<As an aside: If you are interested in having me speak at your Christian conference, church, camp, or university–here’s where you can inquire.>>>



​​​​For the non-pacifist reader…

​​​​So, I don’t know if you agree with me about Jesus and nonviolence. But, if you are a Christian, my guess is that we at least agree on this point: less violence is better than more. Perhaps we can also agree that Jesus is the one who can help us cultivate communities where there is indeed less violence.

Where does this start? Well, one of the places it may start is by committing ourselves to practices that lead us to become more inwardly peaceful.

My hunch is that, pacifist or not, if you engage in spiritual formation exercises with Jesus and you devote some of the spaces of your faith to growing in the “fruit” or virtue of peace, that you will find your impulses toward self-defense begin to become less impulsive. Perhaps you won’t be a pacifist in theory, but when tested, could it be said of you that you didn’t retaliate against your enemy? I think this is more likely than we might think.

Why? Because you have been practicing peace with Jesus for a long time prior.


That’s the vision of nonviolence I’ve come to embrace. As Jesus transforms my heart to be more like his, I hope that my love for neighbors and enemies will override my impulse to fight back. It is not about a theological idea: it is about the humans Jesus invites us to become.

It was ten years ago that I embraced Christian nonviolence. What I’ve learned is that more than merely agreeing with a radical theological idea, Jesus invites me to be embraced by the virtue of peace.

"Okay, didn't realize this was such an old post. Not sure how I ended up ..."

FREE: Missio Alliance Anabaptism Conference Talks
"Looks like it used to be free but the time period on that has expired. ..."

FREE: Missio Alliance Anabaptism Conference Talks
"Seems to only be free for members. Is that correct?"

FREE: Missio Alliance Anabaptism Conference Talks
"i could believe in a god who made a hell cause like it or not ..."

How (Not) to Deconstruct Hell (and ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


TRENDING AT PATHEOS Progressive Christian
What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • jekylldoc

    Love this: peace as an internal virtue, for God to cultivate in us, rather than an ethical principle which we may or may not ever have to decide about. I think an ethical stand, like pacifism, can be a place from which to view the world, and a very insightful one for viewing my internal self.

  • John

    I looked briefly at Anabaptism a few years back, but the strong conviction of pacifism was the show stopper. I have a child who is at a military school and I fully support him. I have no problem with Christians being policeman or soldiers or politicians who may have to put people in harms way. So, I felt like going further would end in disappointment. Other than that, I really like the way Anabaptists practice their faith. One particular story that speaks to me on this issue is when the Centurion comes to Jesus for the healing of his servant. Jesus responds that he has not seen such faith, and that some from far away will enter the kingdom while some of the subject of the kingdom will be tossed out. Jesus made salvific implication of this soldiers faith while making no other requirements from him. Certainly the practice of our faith carries other moral duties, but this incident can spark a conversation at least about Christian vocation where violence is a real possibility. I appreciate that Anabaptist have their theology on this worked out, but I expect that my disagreement would keep me from being a part of that community.