Why Do Christians Love the Idea of Hell? Part Two, The UMC

Why Do Christians Love the Idea of Hell? Part Two, The UMC March 5, 2018

But too many of us are ready to cast those who think differently into hell. I sometimes wonder if this is the unpardonable sin: the taking upon ourselves the right to judge others for all eternity instead of recognizing that this privilege belongs only to God, not to us.

In a previous post, I reviewed the forthcoming Netflix movie, COME SUNDAY, which tells the true story of pastor/evangelist Carlton Pearson and his fall from grace when he realized he could no longer believe in hell. The question that many in his horrified congregation posed after his announcement: “Does this means that everyone is saved?”

Do no one go to hell?
Pearson in dialogue with his horrified associate pastor, Henry (played by Jason Segal)

The question I posed in the original article: “What is it about hell that makes so many Christians giddy with anticipation?”

The question I pose here: “What is it about evolving beliefs that make fellow believers want to cast the questioner into hell?”

Because that has been the pattern all through religious history: Just one deviation from the list of doctrines becomes grounds to tell the searcher, “Go to hell.”

Deep sigh. I have been there. I questioned. Others found the questions threatening to their core beliefs. To maintain their security, it was necessary for them to cast me out. I understand that. I just wonder why we find it so necessary.

In 2005, a joke written by Emo Phillips was voted the Best God Joke ever.

Once I saw this guy on a bridge about to jump.

I said, “Don’t do it!”

He said, “Nobody loves me.”

I said, “God loves you. Do you believe in God?”

He said, “Yes.” I

said, “Are you a Christian or a Jew?”

He said, “A Christian.”

I said, “Me, too! Protestant or Catholic?”

He said, “Protestant.”

I said, “Me, too! What franchise?”

He said, “Baptist.”

I said, “Me, too! Northern Baptist or Southern Baptist?”

He said, “Northern Baptist.”

I said, “Me, too! Northern Conservative Baptist or Northern Liberal Baptist?”

He said, “Northern Conservative Baptist.”

I said, “Me, too! Northern Conservative Baptist Great Lakes Region, or Northern Conservative Baptist Eastern Region?”

He said, “Northern Conservative Baptist Great Lakes Region.”

I said, “Me, too! Northern Conservative†Baptist Great Lakes Region Council of 1879, or Northern Conservative Baptist Great Lakes Region Council of 1912?”

He said, “Northern Conservative Baptist Great Lakes Region Council of 1912.”

I said, “Die, heretic!” And I pushed him over.

Yep, that’s us. That’s what we do. We keep drilling and drilling and drilling trying to force death-inducing but emotionally safe unanimity. The result: commonality is lost, mission is lost, connection is lost, hope is lost.

An important book I read once, Leadership and Self-Deception, reminds us that most people, when stuck in the box of self-deception where it is impossible to see ourselves clearly, classify others as either “allies” or “enemies.”

In other words, while in that box, the world circles around us; our thoughts, our decisions, our viewpoints have more validity, more truth. Other people have no real intrinsic value other than either to serve as reinforcers to what we believe or as opposers to what we think.

Ultimately, other people become good in our sight ONLY if they are in full agreement with us. Otherwise, it is “Die, heretic!” And out they go. They are not fully human, not capable of making reasonable decisions, not able to find wisdom on their own.

It’s difficult to have one’s belief’s challenged, especially when the challengers have developed good and cogent arguments. Becuase of the difficulties, we too frequently work to silence the challengers rather than learn from them. We ultimately become far less whole and healthy because a good challenge offers space to hone our beliefs and also to recognize our human limitations.

At our worst, we lose the ability to acknowledge, “I might be wrong.”

And yes, I might be wrong about where I have moved in my spiritual life. I know for sure that I see an incomplete picture.

But I, as did Carlton Pearson, also changed my beliefs about God’s desire to see most of humanity, past, present and future, suffer in eternal conscious torment. I also changed my views about the nature of human sexuality.

Those viewpoints evolved as I went deeper into the study of the Holy Scriptures, and as I acknowledged with greater frequency my personal limitations in being able to understand and comprehend the nature of God and what it means to live confidently in the midst of God’s love.

Others have also changed their minds, many of them ordained clergy and knowledgeable laity in The United Methodist Church. Yet they still love and wish to remain in full communion with the UMC.  The core convictions remain the same.

Unfortunately, too many, no matter what the theological stance, stand ready to cast those who think differently into hell. I sometimes wonder if this is the unpardonable sin: the taking upon ourselves the right to judge others for all eternity instead of recognizing that this privilege belongs only to God, not to us.

How very easily we deceive ourselves into thinking we have THE final and complete answers to the most difficult questions of life and death.

Photos: Screenshot from the preview provided for me by Netflix of COME SUNDAY;
Book Cover of Leadership and Self Deception from the Amazon.com site.

"a) the mainlines are dying precipitously and have been for decades. "majority" is no longer ..."

The UMC Inquistion Arrived While The ..."
"Oh, brother! I get that you have little idea how conservative religion works within the ..."

The UMC Inquistion Arrived While The ..."
"No, I would not be interested in dodging the theological substance. But the notion that ..."

The UMC Inquistion Arrived While The ..."
"So... you're invoking Christ's dividing the sheep & goats... to tell me I shouldn't invoke ..."

The UMC Inquistion Arrived While The ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

TRENDING AT PATHEOS Progressive Christian
What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Craig

    I gave up the belief in eternal damnation because it cannot be reconciled with an “All Knowing” and “Morally Perfect God”.

  • disqus_ZBXJDbYJHe

    I gave on Hell because I don’t believe that there is a divine person dispensing justice to the wick people. Also, it seems that many of those wick people don’t believe in God or if they did, they feel that their sins will be forgiven despite all the horrible things they did to the human race.

  • Chuck Johnson

    Thanks for the depth of your insight here, Christy.
    The hell stories are crude psychological and political tools.
    Used in the past, but not suitable for the way people think and live today.

  • rtgmath

    Yup. Nicely put. Fundamentalists salivate over the thoughts of their enemies writhing in agony for eternity. I finally came to the understanding that if God considered all who didn’t believe exactly correctly nothing more than disposable trash to torture for ever, then he was nothing more than a monster, or Monster. Sure, He can do Anything. That doesn’t make it Right. I don’t worship Monsters, no matter how powerful.

    So, if God is actually Just and Good, then Hell cannot exist.

  • Janet Follansbee

    As a Christian, I personally dislike the idea of hell as some fiery prison that punishes one for all eternity because of lack of remorse for one’s extreme sinfulness and hubris. Rather, I believe that hell is a perpetual state after death where one will never have the privilege and joy of having a personal relationship with God and living with Him forever in His glorious kingdom. With God, one is never beyond forgiveness or conversion. It is never too late to seek the light that leads to eternal life that is beyond one’s comprehension.

  • YellowBird

    even the worst, most heinous person who ever lived… was once only a baby. maybe was a child that no one even loved. Even Lucifer was once a creation of pure Beauty. Once even he was not evil. in the end, i can never get away from that. i never understood hell, lived in terror of it, but simultaneously could not comprehend its existence. “How can a GOD of LOVE…???” the only answer must be, HE cannot. HE did not. Religion has gotten it all wrong. If Creator is a Being of combined Justice AND Mercy, there can be no prison of never-ending, perpetual, undying torment. Because there is neither Mercy NOR Justice in such a place. And if GOD is All-Powerful, then HE certainly does not have to have such a thing in existence. HE can surely take us all back to The Start.
    Because i Love, because i am capable of Compassion, i know that is what i would do. and it only diminishes Creator to imagine HE would do anything less.
    i think that whatever the lake of fire may be, IF souls are cast in it could ONLY be as part of a PURIFYING PROCESS, and there are scriptures which talk about such, the Refining Fire in which it is only the dross – the spoiled & worthless parts – burnt away leaving all that is PURE & BEAUTIFUL & PRECIOUS & GOOD. Surely Creator cannot be One Who would destroy even the tiniest bit of pure Beauty within any of HIS Creation. Surely HE will save even the most minute particle of Goodness remaining within even the ugliest, most decrepit, ruined, hate-filled soul. It can only be the EVIL that is destroyed… HE will take all that is GOOD back into The Source from which we all came. If HE does anything less, it can only mean HE is not Pure Beauty & Goodness, nor Holiness & Righteousness, nor Love, nor Justice, nor Mercy, in HIMSELF

  • soter phile

    “No one should speak of hell without tears in his eyes.” – Samuel Rutherford

    I tend to agree with Rutherford.
    But Jesus did talk about Hell. A lot. A lot a lot.

    The West loves the idea of a God of Love… but struggles with a God who is Holy.
    To lose either is to lose both. That’s the point of the cross.

  • Brandon Roberts

    as a nonchristian, the idea of truly evil people being tortured for eternity just sounds good.