Fortunate Fall

In case you don’t know by now, Audrey Assad wrote a new album entitled Fortunate Fall, a work full of meat, weight and prayerfulness that you should purchase with your hard-earned dollars to make the world more beautiful. 

I like Audrey’s new record for all the wrong reasons. It stretches away from the “Christian Music Scene,” bridging out into the unknown in an authenticity and a craftsmanship that make up the water and sunlight of good art. First of all, it was created independently, apart from the oh-so-helpful directing influence of a record company — ever with an eye on what the market wants — a company that would inevitably manage to malform at least 3 or 4 of the tracks into easy, accessible radio singles that would “reach so many hearts,” which the Christian equivalent of saying “it will make money.” With the help and expertise of her husband, Audrey raised the funds for the album with an immensely successful Kickstarter campaign, and thus carved out a sacred space of artistic freedom in the creation of Fortunate Fall.

Secondly, and as a result of Audrey’s ditching of the Christian convention, the album itself is dark, simple, and beautiful — like coffee and death. It is the least catchy of her albums, and as such will annoy a lot of people who are wrong in their expectations for Christian artists. Fortunate Fall is full of orchestral breaks, clarinets, a few odd time signatures, and a real sense — and this is the thing — of a suffering strive towards God as opposed to a happy having-found. Perhaps it’s the Catholicism, forever set against the “once saved always saved” mentality in favor of a “fear and trembling,” but Fortunate Fall rips words out of their bright cliches and delivers them against a backdrop of moody, near-contemplative hymnal music. Take Audrey’s take on Psalm 23, a psalm doomed and damned to happy-feels by a multitude of bad repetitions. Audrey’s “Lead Me On” is one of the more typically structured songs on the album, but by giving the verses a musical darkness she allows us to believe in the psalm again, to see it as faith in God that comes out of “the valley of the shadow of death,” and not just from a frolick in the “green pastures.”

YouTube Preview Image

“Your rod and your staff are a strange mercy / In a world where I’m not yet home,” she sings, and it’s that strange mercy that rings around the album, the unexpected, eucatastrophic saving power of God that is terrible and mighty and gentle to behold. Christians have their hands cupped around something unbelievably good, a mystery of salvation beyond anything but beauty to express, a mystery that does not and cannot exclude darkness, uncertainty, and oddity — and Audrey seems to working on expressing it.

But all this brings me to the fact that Audrey Assad’s new album, Fortunate Fall, stinks unapologetically of incense. While the singer-songwriter was never quiet about belonging to the One, Holy, Universal Church, Fortunate Fall busts through the closet and backhands its audience with dark chapels, Latin, hymns by Blessed John Henry Newman, and even a litany:

YouTube Preview Image

Of course, this should all be rather obvious by the title Fortunate Fall, taken from the Exsultet, that ancient chant sung during the Easter Vigil.

O certe necessarium Adae peccatum, quod Christi morte deletum est!
O felix culpa, quae talem ac tantum meruit habere Redemptorem!

O truly necessary sin of Adam, which the death of Christ has blotted out!
O happy fault, that merited such and so great a Redeemer!

But this romance with the Catholic Church seems to be another way the album is branching from the Christian music scene, and for obvious reasons, I dig it. It’s available on Amazon and iTunes – go give it a listen.

The Art of Dying
Man as Art
Millennial Misery
The Mode in Which We Go To Mass
  • Ben McCormack

    “…like coffee and death.” More glowing praise has never been written! [/snark] Very good review, reminds me that I need to re-listen to this album, perhaps while not commuting on the subway (though, really, you might try that; when forced to face humanity while listening to prayerful contemplation, Christianity gets really dirty. This album fits).

  • Martin T.
  • Fr. Darryl

    I am seriously planning to make this album the subject of a retreat in the future. Stunningly beautiful, poignant, and prayerful. Thank you, Audrey!

  • AMoniqueOcampo

    In other words…SHUT UP AND TAKE MY MONEY! Audrey Assad is my new favorite singer and I got introduced to her through the song “Slow,” which is a lot like what this album is like: a slow ride that reflects the ups and downs of having faith.

  • John Lo

    Hello, I’ve been reading your posts for quite awhile and I really appreciate what you’ve written so far. In your appreciation of christian music that doesn’t sound too “christian”, I have a feeling you may enjoy Thrice, where Dustin Kensrue has been quite the amazing lyricist.

  • Daniel Piscoya

    I would never have realized this album’s immense beauty if you had not piqued my curiosity into listening to it. THANK YOU

  • w

    hey marc,

    do check out danielle rose – she composed a tune for the litany of humility. (how badass is that? you’ve got to at least listen to it once:!/s/Litany+Of+Humility/3nBTRB?src=5)

    • Martin T.

      . . . badass. . . Litany of Humility. . . . :) nice contrast.

  • Th0t

    Give “Universal” by FoundNation a listen!! You won’t regret it B)
    And also the free downloadable album named Refreshed Thoughts on !

  • MoLeland

    Thank you for introducing me to the music of Audrey Assad. I had never heard of her until reading this blog post. It has been a long, long time since I was last moved by music in such a powerful way.

  • Bob

    Also an absolute must:
    The whole album is free to listen on their website.


    Beautiful cover! I appreciate simplicity in our busy world around us.

  • cheytewa

    I only very recently discovered this blog, and I had never heard of this artist – thank you for both! I love all kinds of music but it’s rare that I am bought to tears by it – Assad did that to me.

  • QDefenestration

    I took an extended hiatus from reading Bad Catholic. Your best articles were always, imo, those that dealt with art/artistic endeavor.

    This was simply an excellent review. Thank you.