A Vatican observer weighs in on Tim Tebow

The director of the “Church and Sport” section at the Pontifical Council for the Laity — yes, there is such a section at the Vatican — has offered a few thoughts on the Tim Tebow phenomenon.


Legionary of Christ Father Kevin Lixey works in the Roman Curia helping the Church make a contribution to the world of sport, with the aim of promoting a sports culture suitable to the integral development of the individual.

ZENIT spoke with Father Lixey about the Denver Broncos quarterback, Tim Tebow, after Tebow led his team to an overtime win in last Sunday’s playoff game.

Those familiar with the NFL — and even those who are not — might have heard of Tebow for more than his unique style as a quarterback. His outward expressions of his Christian faith are being talked about by all sorts of commentators, in the world of American football and beyond. Though certainly not the only athlete to publicly express his faith on the field, Tebow is drawing more attention than usual. We asked Father Lixey what he thinks about that.

ZENIT: Do you see Tim Tebow’s public expression of faith as a positive or negative phenomenon? Certainly it is drawing a lot of attention to Christ, in one form or another …

Father Lixey: The hype over Tim Tebow is certainly an interesting phenomenon in an ever more secularized world. I consider it something very positive. Even at the college level, while quarterback for the Florida Gators during the 2009 Bowl Championship Series title contest, Tebow wrote “John 3:16″ on his eye black. The Palm Beach Post reported that 92 million people Googled the verse following the game … impressive!

But, it is not the mere public expression of faith — as Tebow drops a knee to give thanks after a touchdown, or prays with other players who include teammates and opponents after the game — that is attracting people; it is his entire person.

I had the chance to speak with the offensive coordinator who coached Tim at the Florida Gators. He said he was a very unique player who was spiritually on another stratosphere with respect to the rest of the team. Yet, Tim was respected by his teammates because he was genuine. And this is the point I would like to touch on. As one reporter noted (Chuck Klosterman, Dec. 6, 2011): “This, I think, is what makes Tebow so maddening to those who hate him: He refuses to say anything that would validate the suspicion that he’s fake (or naïve or self-righteous or dumb).”

While Tebow certainly sticks out for these external manifestations of his faith, not to mention his unorthodox playing style as an NFL quarterback, his personal background is also not typical for an NFL quarterback. It is a real “Cinderella” story — although those who have to tackle Tim would not consider him a Cinderella.

ZENIT: OK, but does prayer really have a place in football? Surely God doesn’t care about who wins the Super Bowl — or does he?

Father Lixey: Judging from his public statements, Tebow is one of the few and most prominent religious athletes to recognize that God does not care about the score of football games. Tebow considers his missionary and philanthropic work much more important than football, but at the same time, possible, because of it. We all too often equate prayer with only asking good things from God, where prayer is only used “to obtain something” i.e., victory, health, or a miracle. The Catechism reminds us that prayer is also “the raising of one’s mind and heart to God” and that we “we must remember God more often that we draw breath.”

Certainly there are moments and places more conducive to prayer, but there is no reason that all religious manifestations be entirely banned from the public square. These external manifestations of one’s beliefs are impressive precisely because they are public. Just as Christians once fell to their knees at the sound of the Angelus bell to remember the Incarnation, or just as the cab driver makes the point of getting out of his car to bow down toward Mecca in prayer, I see no reason why a professional football player cannot offer a prayer of thanksgiving or point to heaven instead of doing a lewd victory dance in the end zone.

ZENIT: As Catholics, what can we learn from this situation — from Tebow himself, perhaps, and from the reactions he’s causing?

Father Lixey: Blessed John Paul II once reminded a group of top professional soccer players: “The eyes of sports fans throughout the world are fixed on you. Be conscious of your responsibility! It is not only the champion in the stadium but also the whole person who should become a model for millions of young people, who need ‘leaders,’ not ‘idols.’ They need men who can convey to them the zest for challenge, a sense of discipline, the courage to be honest and the joy of unselfishness.”

I believe Tim Tebow is trying to live up to these words of John Paul II and his example can prompt other athletes to be “leaders” and not idols, being a model on and off the field, especially of the corporal works of mercy. As Tim shares in his own words: “When I was a student at the University of Florida, I found great joy in taking time to encourage children suffering from cancer in hospitals or visiting a prison or juvenile detention center, or doing mission work with my family at Uncle Dick’s Orphanage in the Philippines. … Football is so popular (that) it enables an athlete like me to establish a platform for doing good deeds … to take this experience to an even greater level of outreach and influence. … After my professional career, I plan on giving my life full time to this outreach.”

There’s more.  Read it all.

Meantime, Dan Barry of the New York Times has a few thoughts on the Tebow Phenom:

What, exactly, is it about Tim Tebow that so fascinates and provokes us? Why do some people project onto him the best of this country (humility, tenacity, plain old decency) — and the worst (sanctimoniousness, overexposure, political intolerance)?

Part of the answer may lie in the way he seems oblivious to the throaty roars that envelop him on and off the field, as though Tebow is always tebowing, whether kneeling or standing up. It seems a stretch to interpret his calm indifference as a particularly arrogant strain of piety. More likely, it is his way of saying that none of this — the rah-rah football Sunday, followed by the weeklong football Kremlinology — is what truly matters.

Tebow may not think that Tebow is what matters, but much of the country apparently does. Why?

Legions of pundits, writers and insomniac callers to late-night radio have analyzed the subject. But maybe no investigation or deep sociological inquiry is required. Maybe the key to the Tebow phenomenon is just this: He wins games.

What’s more, Tebow tends to win in the closing minutes, against considerable odds and amid the persistent doubts about his ability by the football establishment. He often can seem like a regular guy suddenly thrust into the middle of a professional football game, only to win by summoning a superhuman will that we all wish we had.

Finally, and it cannot be denied, Tebow’s very public conviction about his faith resonates (Isn’t he a model for how to live?), intrigues (How can he be so certain?) or annoys (Can’t he keep it in the church pew?). If he were not in the playoffs, perhaps we would not care as much. But since he is, his extraordinary athleticism and proven heroics — including two college championships and a Heisman Trophy — are routinely forgotten in favor of a more mystical possibility.


  1. JPII sure did cut to the chase when he told the athletes they were called to be leaders, not idols.

    This guy has had a big “X” on his back since he was a college freshman. Certainly he must do something wrong? Cutoff someone on the freeway when driving ? Breakup awkwardly with a past girlfriend? Say a bad word when the hammer hits his finger? He never claims to be perfect it should be noted.

    It is interesting to read and hear what his former coaches and teammates say:

    *he is the ” real deal” (ie. he really is a gentleman, and a good teammate and a good person etc)
    *his success is not done on the cheap– he is a hard worker , in the weight room, film study, practice – always working hard to learn, grow. In other words a coach’s dream.
    * while public about his religion and beliefs, he was not about pushing his religious precepts on his teammates or others.
    * he has the “it” of leadership– and is able to get his teammates to believe in him and believe he will lead them to success.

    Lastly is this line from the NYT story above, which may say more about modern society and our diminished expectations for young people today then about Tebow.

    In 2009, a reporter at a news conference asked Tebow whether he was “saving” himself for marriage. When the virile young college hero answered yes, many in the room were so dumbstruck that he jokingly wondered whether he had just stunned the reporters into silence.

  2. I just saw this link– this just about seals the deal

  3. pagansister says:

    IMO, he is probably as nice as folks say—and that is to his credit, but personally, why does he find it necessary to so overtly have to express his “faith” constantly? Why the display?

  4. ron chandonia says:

    That link says it all. Tebow’s theology may not be Catholic, but he is constantly demonstrating a love for people on the margins of life that all Christians would do well to emulate.

  5. I don’t see it as a display – I see him as someone who recognizes from whom all his gifts come and he openly acknowledges that – and I also think that is pretty neat and inspirational :)

  6. friscoeddie says:

    It’s half time right now, but Tom Brady, a Bay Area guy and an Irish Catholic, has thrown 5 tds in the first half. We will wait for the game final to call who heaven is really rooting for…. Heaven has already signaled it’s the 49ers in the NFC championship game. (-: (-:

  7. friscoeddie says:

    Game over.. 6 tds for the Catholic.. Vatican Sports please note /copy.. (-:

  8. pagansister says:

    IMO, Annie he could do some of his thanking in private—perhaps in the locker room. Again, IMO, EVERYTIME he makes a positive contribution to the game, plopping down on one knee every, every time is a “display”, and quite honestly, overkill. Once or twice—OK, but every cotton-pickin time? Really? Over kill.

  9. naturgesetz says:

    So he’s allowed to thank God for some big plays but not others?

  10. Patrick Sweeney says:

    Tebow’s acknowledgement of God would have not even been noticed in the 1960′s. Our society has moved from being tolerant, to indifferent, to intolerant of piety in the public square. Religious freedom isn’t about “freedom from religion”, but without the good example of Tebow and others, people will begin to think that religion in public is contrary to law, culture, and common sense.

  11. “Tebow’s acknowledgement of God would have not even been noticed in the 1960′s.”

    As I recall, the practice of one’s religion was a much more private affair then. I can’t think of any public figure who would have made such a public display in the 1960s. (Not that I have a problem with it.) Do you have any examples?

  12. friscoeddie says:

    “Do you have any examples?

    In the early 50s Notre Dame vs Army was the biggest game in the US, every year. Pro football then was giving away tickets to get interest. NYC Catholic ethnics who couldn’t find So. Bend on a map made such a deal rooting for ND that the games was fazed out because the gambling/rivalry on a ‘religious’ game was frowned upon. Where do you think the Hail Mary pass came from? Athiest U?

  13. No, friscoeddie, I do not think that the term, “Hail Mary “ pass originated at Atheist U. but I not convinced that it originated at Notre Dame, as some of us Notre Dame fans would like to think. I’m more convinced that it originated in 1975 with Dallas Cowboys quarterback Roger Staubach, a devout Catholic, who described to the press his winning pass in a playoff game against the Minnesota Vikings, “I closed my eyes and said a Hail Mary.”

    By the way, I just saw a ”Hail Mary” Pass by Eli Manning with 6 seconds to play to the end of the first half of the New York Giants vs. Green Bay Packers game. The announcer just called it a “Hail Mary.”

  14. After I wrote my original comment on this post, I remembered going to the Palestra in Philadelphia to watch the “big five” teams (Penn, Temple Villanova, St. Joe’s and La Salle) play. I recalled all the times I saw one of the players from the three Catholic schools bless himself at the foul line.

  15. pagansister says:

    Yep! :o)

Leave a Comment