“Wonder” and the Paradoxes of Living with a Disability

R.J. Palacio’s young adult novel Wonder tells the story of Auggie, a boy with a severe facial deformity who goes to school for the first time in fifth grade. He confronts fear and bullies, but also makes friends—even with some of the very same kids who initially teased him. I thought it was a beautiful story, for both kids and adults (we read it as part of a parent/child book group at church). One thing that the author did particularly well was capture some of the paradoxes of living with an outward and obvious medical condition.

Throughout the book, Auggie notes the way people react upon first seeing his face. They look away, or stare, or smile extra big. Toddlers sometimes cry in fear and confusion. Auggie hates this, steeling himself for any situation (like the first day in his new school) where there will be lots of people who have never seen him before. But underneath his pain and exasperation is a trace of empathy. He understands that a face so unusual will attract attention, that people will wonder why he looks the way he does.

As someone with a pronounced limp and scars who has also been the object of stares or open curiosity in public, I understand the two forces pulling at Auggie—frustration at not being able to just blend in like everyone else, but a little empathy too, for people whose curiosity is understandable.

At the end of the book [spoiler alert], Auggie gets an award at fifth grade graduation. As he takes in the standing ovation given by the other students, their families, and his teachers, Auggie is thinking:

I wasn’t even sure why I was getting this medal, really.

No, that’s not true. I knew why.

It’s like people you see sometimes, and you can’t imagine what it would be like to be that person, whether it’s somebody in a wheelchair or somebody who can’t talk. Only, I know that I’m that person to other people, maybe to every single person in that whole auditorium.

To me, though, I’m just me. An ordinary kid.

But hey, if they want to give me a medal for being me, that’s okay. I’ll take it. I didn’t destroy a Death Star or anything like that, but I did just get through the fifth grade. And that’s not easy, even if you’re not me.

I loved that passage. Auggie’s insistence that he’s “just me…an ordinary kid” very gently chides our cultural tendency to consider people with disabilities extraordinary just for doing all the regular things that people do. There’s something a little patronizing about that attitude, a subtle implication that people with disabilities should be acclaimed simply for getting out of bed in the morning, rather than hiding ourselves away and feeling sorry for ourselves. At the same time, Auggie also understands that others don’t see him as ordinary. He knows that, in some ways, he’s not. He also understands that everyone, whether they live with a disability or not, does hard things. Like getting through fifth grade. The book ends a few pages later with a precept that Auggie submitted to his English teacher as part of an assignment:

Everyone in the world should get a standing ovation at least once in their life because we all overcometh the world.

There can be a tendency—in the media, in public and private discourse—to paint people with disabilities with an overly broad brush. We are heroes to be exalted. We are burdens to be pitied. Even those affected by various conditions can oversimplify the experience of living with a disability, reducing disability to a value-neutral “difference” in a way that fails to name the significant pain and impairments (of many kinds) that can accompany various conditions. Some pain associated with disabilities has nothing to do with social inclusion or exclusion, accommodations or barriers, but is inherent to the condition itself.

In my experience, living with a disability is full of paradox. The push-pull of anger and empathy when people stare or don’t know what to do or say, the knowledge that we are utterly ordinary but also not, that we are no different from anyone else who has to do hard things (which is everyone) but also, yeah, have to deal with lots of hard stuff much of the time—those are the paradoxes that R.J. Palacio deftly illustrates with her wise and gracious (but also ordinary—there is lots of bathroom humor in Wonder) 11-year-old protagonist.

About Ellen Painter Dollar

Ellen Painter Dollar is a writer focusing on faith, parenting, family, disability, and ethics. She is the author of No Easy Choice: A Story of Disability, Faith, and Parenthood in an Age of Advanced Reproduction (Westminster John Knox, 2012). Visit her web site at http://ellenpainterdollar.com for more on her writing and speaking, and to sign up for a (very) occasional email newsletter.

  • http://timfall.wordpress.com/ Tim

    Everyone should get a medal or award or standing ovation at some point, because everyone does something along the way that took extraordinary effort, even if it might have been something another person could have done effortlessly. And all those people cold echo Auggie and say “But I’m just me.” How true that is. And how wonderful, too.

  • pastordt

    Thanks for these insights, Ellen – his and your own. I do have a tendency to think of those who deal with chronic illness or disability as somehow more heroic than the rest of us. And in some ways, I probably always will. Because life is hard for everyone. And I guess it just feels to me that laying illness or disability on top of that is worth admiration. I hope it’s not patronizing because I surely don’t mean it to be.

    • http://ellenpainterdollar.com/ Ellen Painter Dollar

      And there are times, when I’m dealing with the hard parts of the disability my daughter and I live with, that I would agree that we sometimes have it way harder than lots of people…even if everyone deals with “hard” sometimes. And then other times I think we’re just ordinary folk, dealing with hard stuff as everyone does. That’s what I loved about Auggie’s insights: He sees both sides. It’s both/and, not either/or. Which is how I tend to see most things having to do with disability!