Why I Stopped Feeling Guilty for Wanting a Beautiful Home

For years, I pored over magazine spreads and home catalogs, made graph-paper renderings of kitchen plans, and daydreamed of white Shaker cabinets, the perfect sectional sofa, and a sun-drenched window seat. I felt guilty for my materialism, for how much I cared about such superficial things, because I believed that a good Christian shouldn’t (not guilty enough to give up the daydreaming, though).

Forget the “prosperity gospel,” the (rightfully maligned) view that material wealth proves God’s favor. My progressive Christian circles espoused a “simplicity gospel,” whereby your faith could be measured in part by how little you cared about material things. In my 20s, I was the best-dressed person in my edgy coffeehouse church — not because I had money to spend on designer fashions (I didn’t), but because I was one of the few people who bought new clothes at all. In that church culture, new-and-expensive anything was spiritually suspect.

One friend regularly spoke, with bewildered embarrassment, of the $900 chair he had once bought, much as one might recall a teenaged shoplifting incident. “Detachment” was the name of the game; I recall a preacher speaking that word with such precision — de-TACH-ment — that she nearly embodied the unburdened single-mindedness with which we were to approach God, free of material distractions. I squirmed in my tailored black pantsuit and thought guiltily of my apartment, with the new sofabed and armchair that I so loved to look at, sit in, and offer to guests.

Just by happenstance, several essays I’ve written for other people/sites have all been posted this week. Continue reading this one at OnFaith.

 

"as a disabled person my two cents is of course we deserve human treatment of ..."

Disability as the Last Acceptable Prejudice: ..."
"Sad article to contemplate. Personally I believe if you don't have compassion for the disabled ..."

Disability as the Last Acceptable Prejudice: ..."
"If the time is right for you to write a piece for the Disability series, ..."

Disability as the Last Acceptable Prejudice: ..."
"Such a wonderful post that I will return to again and again for many reasons. ..."

Disability as the Last Acceptable Prejudice: ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • pastordt

    So, SO sorry about that comment stream, Ellen. Sheesh.

    • http://ellenpainterdollar.com/ Ellen Painter Dollar

      Thanks Diana. I made a mistake in engaging that commenter. Early on, s/he said some things that gave the impression that s/he was open to actual conversation. But then, no matter what my response, s/he read all sorts of weird and inaccurate things into my statements (e.g., that I think that God *gave* me my nice house so I wouldn’t waste my time coveting other people’s homes, etc.). So I realized too late that I was engaged in a futile conversation. I’m usually pretty good at figuring out when to just leave a comment thread be…but I made the wrong judgment call this time! Thanks for reading and responding.