I have to say it’s been a surprise to hear so consistently about the end of American evangelicalism. My own experience with the tradition goes back a long ways to my marginal participation in Young Life (mostly because of friends and girls) and then on and off in various groups in college. But the break was solidified the night I attended a Josh McDowell revival at my university; midway through I walked out. I couldn’t take the idea that anyone could seriously try to “prove” faith by trying to proof text the resurrection. I walked home to my apartment and began reading Soren Kierkegaard’s Concept of Dread. I felt relief.
Fast-forward to my second book, Evangelicals vs. Liberals: The Clash of Christian Cultures in the Pacific Northwest, in which I mapped the incredible power and growth of evangelical churches in the putatively ‘secular’ Pacific Northwest. It was 2007, I thought at that time the evangelical civic religion was at the very heart of American religious, cultural and political life. Evangelicalism seemed like a force that had the ability to maintain itself as a social and a political movement for a long time. But low and behold, with the multiple missteps of the George W. Bush administration, the fiasco of the Iraq War, the election of Barack Obama, the growing groundswell of support for gay marriage, suddenly the civil and religious landscape of American religion flipped. A new evocative secular and even atheist force has made its voice and power known in American culture and politics. How did this all happen? Well, in part, this blog will try to answer some of those questions and grapple with the changes that have occurred and continue to disrupt the American religious landscape.
To be sure, we now live in an open religious market and America’s religious subculture’s must adjust and respond to that culture. This is not to say that religious cultures aren’t thriving. I’m now writing a book on American Megachurches, which will show that megachurches are one of the primary ways American do their religion today. But that story is for another time. Nonetheless, the ground beneath American religion is shifting—and that is exactly what makes it so exciting to explore.
I start with David E. Fitch’s excellent work on The End of Evangelicalism, and his more recent book, Prodigal Christianity: 10 Signposts into the Missional Frontier. I think both are worth exploring. The End of Evangelicalism, charts how the trinity of evangelicalism has collapsed: 1) the inerrant Bible, 2) the call for conversion to Christ, and, 3) the Christian nation. The last is perhaps most obvious for many evangelicals. The cultural shift on gay marriage alone is enough to make conservatives claim that the nation has “fallen.” The problems with inerrancy have been thoroughly eviscerated in Christian Smith’s recent book, Bible Made Impossible: Why Biblicism Is Not a Truly Evangelical Reading of Scripture. Fitch’s book is a fascinating exploration of the wreckage of evangelical culture. He uses the Slavoj Žižek, the Slovenian cultural critic, to announce the “empty politic” of evangelical culture in which belief and action are divorced. Fitch wants a missional and incarnational faith that he brings together belief and action in an unbreakable unity.
For Fitch, evangelicalism has become an ideology, which is, as he says, “empty at its core.” That is belief has been thoroughly instrumentalized and used as a weapon in the culture wars—as a club, as it were, to assault opponents and to defend specific political rostrums. This culture war is exactly what has repulsed so many young evangelicals. The ideology of the culture war has been an ill-fated attempt to maintain the status quo. This kind of naked political power as rightly noted, by Fitch, has little to do with the gospel. For Fitch, something terrible has gone wrong. In this midst of this wreckage, as Fitch notes, “irruptions of the Real” show the poverty of the present, and in coming blogs I’ll explore these irruptions and the “signposts” of the real. For now, I’ll go back to reading Soren Kierkegaard’s Attack upon Christendom. What a relief.