Her argument goes something like this: Pagans need the authority and consistency that only scripture gives, Pagans have already given authority to authors, eventually Pagans will select certain texts to “slowly form a set of scriptures and commentary, much like Judaism.”
A lot of people have compared today’s Paganism to first-century Christianity, including me. But that comparison only goes so far. The volume of written works is thousands of times greater today – there is little mystery around the written word, and there is no need to slavishly copy a few books and letters. While I think all inspiration is Divine, no Pagan books are thought to be direct revelations from God/dess (it’s my amateur opinion that few if any writers of the Bible thought they were writing scripture, and many would be shocked at the way their words are used today). Essentially, the conditions necessary for canonizing certain writings as scripture don’t exist in our world.
Star acknowledges that Paganism is very diverse, individualistic and anti-authoritarian, and that this limits our ability to come together to form a unified, powerful Pagan community. My opinion is that while this may point toward a need for scripture, it’s yet another reason why we’ll never have it.
I touched on this two weeks ago in a blog post on the future of Pagan leadership. The second generation of Pagan leaders have been authors. But the spread of Paganism and the explosion of the internet have further decentralized what was already a pretty scattered group. Our future is as a collection of individuals who form families of Wiccans, Druids, Heathens, UU Pagans and other flavors, and who occasionally work together in a loose confederation called Paganism.
As much as I like organization and structure, I think our decentralized, organic approach is better. As soon as you establish scripture, myths stop evolving and morals become frozen in time. Our world is changing too fast – our religion has to keep up with it.
I’m a Druid in the Order of Bards, Ovates and Druids. I’m an ordained priest in the Universal Gnostic Fellowship. I’m the Coordinating Officer of the Denton, Texas Covenant of Unitarian Universalist Pagans. This year I’m also serving as a member of the Board of Trustees of CUUPS National. I’m a member of the Denton Unitarian Universalist Fellowship.
I write as a spiritual practice. It helps me organize my thoughts and work through ideas and concepts. It helps me evaluate my beliefs and practices against my core values and against what I know (or at least, what I think I know) to be true. It helps me interpret my experiences (religious and otherwise) in ways that are both meaningful and honest.