Pope Francis Contradicts Himself!

On that thing he never said in the first place!

Just after (reportedly) announcing “Abortion fiesta!  No problem! Lighten up, Catholics!” he now tells doctors not to perform abortions!  Press baffled!

Chesterton, as is his custom, gets the confusion of the media, which was exactly the same a century ago:

The great temptation of the Catholic in the modern world is the temptation to intellectual pride. It is so obvious that most his critics are talking without in the least knowing what they are talking about, that he is sometimes a little provoked towards the very un-Christian logic of answering a fool according to his folly.  He is a little bit disposed to luxuriate in secret, as it were over the much greater subtlety and richness of the philosophy he inherits; and only answer a bewildered barbarian so as to bewilder him still more.  He is tempted to ironical agreements or even to disguising himself as a dunce. Men who have an elaborate philosophical defence of their views sometimes take pleasure in boasting of their almost babyish credulity. Having reached their own goal through labyrinths of logic, they will point the stranger only to the very shortest short cut of authority; merely in order to shock the simpleton with simplicity. Or, as in the present case, they will find a grim amusement in presenting the separate parts of the scheme as if they were really separate; and leave the outsider to make what he can of them. So when somebody says that a fast is the opposite to a feast, and yet both seem to be sacred to us, some of us will always be moved merely to say, “Yes,” and relapse into an objectionable grin. When the anxious ethical enquirer says, “Christmas is devoted to merry-making, to eating meat and drinking wine, and yet you encourage this pagan and materialistic enjoyment,” you or I will be tempted to say, “Quite right, my boy,” and leave it at that. When he then says, looking even more worried, “Yet you admire men for fasting in caves and deserts and denying themselves ordinary pleasures; you are clearly committed, like the Buddhists, to the opposite or ascetic principle,” we shall be similarly inspired to say, “Quite correct, old bean,” or “Got it first time, old top,” and merely propose an adjournment for convivial refreshment.

Nevertheless, it is a temptation to be resisted. Not only is it obviously our duty to explain to the other people that what seems to them contradictory is really complementary, but we are not altogether justified in any such tone of superiority. We are not right in making our geniality an expression of our despair. We are not entitled to despair of explaining the truth; nor is it really so horribly difficult to explain.  The real difficulty is not so much that the critic is crude as that we ourselves are not always clear, even in our own minds, far less in our public expositions. It is not so much that they are not subtle enough to understand it, as that they and we and everybody else are not simple enough to understand it.  Those two things are obviously part of one thing, if we are straightforward enough to look at the thing; and to see it simply as it is.

Mirabile dictu, the Pope can emphasize that the encounter between Jesus and each human person (aka, “Love the Lord with heart, soul, mind and strength) is the most important thing and yet also say that the defense of innocent human life (aka, “Love your neighbor as yourself”) is also important.

Like Patheos Catholic on Facebook!


Where in the US is Flat Francis?
Funniest Thing I've Seen This Month
Pope Receives Summer Re-Education Camp Arts and Crafts Project
Fr. Robert Barron on Laudato Si and the Pope's Recent Comments on Capitalism