Here is the original Top Ten list from the National Catholic Register:
I asked for titles of other films about priests; here are some of the titles sent in
Diary of a Country Priest
True Confessions
Black Robe
Boys Town
Into Great Silence – monastic and only some are priests but it is a way of life
Mass Appeal
The Third Miracle
Molokai: The Story of Father Damien
Romero (more than the Archbishop; the three other priests)
Keeping the Faith