“GET OUT”: Rick Santorum’s Christian Exceptionalism

“GET OUT”: Rick Santorum’s Christian Exceptionalism March 30, 2012

On March 19th, Rick Santorum was canvassing Louisiana in an attempt to woo voters when he accepted an invitation to speak at Greenwell Springs Baptist Church in Baton Rouge. He was introduced by Pastor Dennis E. Terry who delivered what has since become an infamous sermon as an introduction for Santorum.

There are so many disturbing elements to this video that it’s hard to know where to start. And though it is important to note that Santorum did not say these things, he has had more than a week to condemn them, or at least distance himself from them. He has done neither.  In fact, he joined in the standing ovation that Terry received at the end of his speech, and he also accepted  blessing from the pastor during the same event.

All of this places Santorum in the position of tacitly condoning Pastor Terry’s vitriolic screed, which points precisely to why I called Santorum a “Champion of the Secular Left” in an earlier article. In allying himself with such a rigidly conservative constituency, he now represents these views in the eyes of other Americans. And if the majority of responses I’ve seen from folks across the board to Terry’s sermon, the push-back against this kind of Christianity will be a net-negative for both Santorum and Terry.

The thing is, it doesn’t matter for Terry. In fact, in as much as he perpetuates the evangelical mantra of being martyred in the court of public opinion, the backlash he’s receiving only serves to reinforce that the world is out to get him. But Santorum cannot afford the same kind of broad-based PR damage. He has to appeal to a larger audience, but he’s tied himself to a narrow cross-section of America that could not care less about being accepted in the mainstream.

Politically, this spells nothing but disaster.

As for Terry’s sermon, there are several points that stood out to me, to which I feel like I have to offer a response. Let’s get the most obvious one out of the way first: the “Get Out” statement.

Nuance it however you like, but what Pastor Terry is calling for is ethnic cleansing. Sure, it’s not the Nuremberg style of ethnic cleansing, but it is precisely that. Taking a hard line, staking a claim that this is how “we” do things and offering up all who differ an ultimatum to concede or leave is not far removed from Nazi exceptionalist rhetoric.

I don’t throw that word around casually either. It’s en vogue to label anyone who holds different views than us as a Nazi, and I’m not calling Terrie one. I’m certainly not suggesting Santorum is. But I will stand behind the assertion that the kind of exceptionalist rhetoric Terry offered at Santorum’s rally is entirely consistent with the Nazi approach to separating the sheep from the goats, using their own custom-made criteria, of course.

I won’t even bother to dissect Terry’s positions on things like abortion, homosexuality or the preservation of traditional marriage, as these are time-tested components of the social conservative platform, shared both by churches and politicians like Santorum. Nothing shocking there. Nauseating, yes. Shocking, no.

But there are a few theological issues I have to take with Terry’s sermon. For one, he espouses what I call “Jesus worship,” which is something that has bothered me for a long time about evangelical theology. While Jesus himself said, time and again that (to paraphrase) “it’s not about me, but rather about the One who sent me,” most evangelical Christians seem intent on ignoring Jesus’ own directive here. Jesus did not seek to be worshiped.

Yes, he allowed a woman to pour perfume on his feet, as he seemed to understand that people tended to cling to what they could see and touch. But he urged us not to stop there. He wanted us to look beyond him to God, using him as a means to seek God. But despite this, plenty of Christians still get caught up in the misdirected practice of Jesus-worship.

Second, Terry’s Christian exceptionalism with regard to other religions is simply founded on ignorance. In one breath, he says “we” Christians worship the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, but then he says we don’t worship “Allah,” the Muslim name for God. Now, I’m no religious history scholar, but I’m pretty sure we can trace Christianity, Judaism and Islam back to the God claimed by Abraham, Isaac and Jacob.

Finally, there’s a falsely claimed sense of victimization in his sermon that is often employed in the Christian “culture wars.” Terry says he’s tired of being told he can’t say the things he wants to say about his faith, and then he proceeds to say what he wants to say about his faith. Yes, he is being criticized for it, but being allowed to say what you choose is different than expecting to be able to say it without any consequence.

But the adversarial nature of his argument is necessary to keep the us-versus-them dichotomy going. This is the fuel for the culture war, which only the Christian right, such as the likes of Terry, seem to be waging. But it galvanizes followers around a clear common cause, and it gives them something both to be angry about and afraid of. Since fear and anger are essential components to the platform of the Christian right, Terry et al can’t drop the rhetoric, absurd and out of touch as it may sound.

Yes, you can pray in school and in other public places. You just can’t make everyone else pray the way you want them to. Yes, you can say what you believe in public. You just can’t expect to have everyone offer a standing ovation like Santorum did.

A good leader in the political sphere is synthetic, not in the sense that they are fake, but rather in that they bring disparate groups together. But the primary purpose of this kind of harsh religious rhetoric is to divide, and not only that, but also to suppress those not of like mind as inferior.

It may be ideal for building up a baptist church in Baton Rouge, but it’s un-Christlike. and it’s also poor political strategy. Santorum has dug his own political grave.

"This blog is dated March 2016. It wasn't that good then and it's no better ..."

Five Ways “Representative Democracy” is Failing ..."
"sounds cool."

"I believe taking calculated risk are super important. having the faith that it will work ..."

25 Christian Blogs You Should Be ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

TRENDING AT PATHEOS Progressive Christian
What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Anonymous

    Link needs corrected dude.

  • Again, really hoping you’re right about Santorum.

  • First of all, I’m in a world religions class right now (really interesting, I’m going to be writing a blog soon on Islam now that we’ve had a guest speaker, that was awesome), so I can tell you: You’re right.  “Allah” is not a different name, it’s just the Arabic word for “God” (like “Yahweh” for the Jews), and Allah IS also the god of Abraham, etc, which means that Allah and God are one and the same. So, yes, we actually DO worship Allah…we just don’t call him that.

    Also, Muhammad is not a separate god, or even considered the savior.  Muslims believe Muhammad was the last prophet of God.  They also consider Abraham, Noah, and Jesus as prophets.  So in that respect they’re no different than Jews, thank you.

    AND, Buddhism is arguably not even a religion.  SOME Buddhists look on the Buddha as a godlike figure, but he did not set himself up as a god – his real name was Prince Something-or-other, and he wanted to find Nirvana (and get out of the cycle of reincarnation), and he meditated and came up with various paths to a good life, and thus Nirvana. Although it’s considered a religion, Buddhism in my opinion is more of a philosophy as there’s no deity involved. At any rate, Buddha is not worshiped even by most Buddhists, so that was just a bad example on the part of this guy.

    People like this just frustrate me. Although, if Santorum is alienating himself from voters by not distancing himself from this sort of crap, I’m okay with that. I refuse to recognize him as a Catholic. He’s giving the rest of us a bad name.

  • Michael Rowzee

    Hey Rick, before you quit can you tell us why you did these crazy things?

    Santorum put the screws to elderly veterans.

    Santorum: “People Have This Idea That They Should Be Left Alone”
    They have this idea that people should be left alone, be able to do whatever
    they want to do, government should keep our taxes down, keep our regulations
    low, and that we shouldn’t get involved in the bedroom, we shouldn’t get
    involved in cultural issues. That is not how traditional conservatives view the
    world. There is no such society that I am aware of, where we’ve had
    radical individualism and that it succeeds as a culture. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Gwwmm-cQxU&feature=player_embedded

    How Corrupt Was Santorum? http://andrewsullivan.thedailybeast.com/2012/01/the-corrupt-christianist.html

    Santorum charity for the poor spent most of its money on management,
    political friends

    Why Rick Santorum’s Pennsylvania Residency Scam and School Tuition Fraud
    Still Matters – And Why He Can’t Be the Nominee Because of It