AWESOME COMMENTS THREAD: “An inquirer comes to you. Asks you what’s so great about being Catholic. What do you say?”
I guess if I had to say something that hasn’t been said better in the comments thread, I’d say, 1) The cabhorse in “The Preludes” and the sparrow in Hamlet mean something for Catholics; and 2) Catholicism knows why you aren’t a Catholic, or a Christian, yet. Knows, understands, forgives; challenges.
But mostly I’d just say what everyone says: the Eucharist.