ADDITIONS AND CORRECTIONS: SONS AND DAUGHTERS OF HOLY MOTHER CHURCH EDITION.

Aelred: Well, so I’m a moron. For some reason I thought, on first reading, that St. Aelred didn’t grasp or address the sacrifices necessary for friendship. In fact, he says that friends should endure “crucifixion” for one another (with all that implies).

One, I’m an idiot, and two, you absolutely should read Spiritual Friendship, which I think is the most amazing neo-Platonist document I’ve read barring The Confessions which is kind of an unfair comparison. Aelred understands Plato’s method as well as his conclusions; so if it’s the Platonic method you love–which you should, since that’s the point–you should read Spiritual Friendship immediately after The Symposium. It’s actually more neo-Platonist than The Confessions.

St. Therese: So I had a conversation with the friend who had recommended Maurice and Therese, after I dissed it on the blog. And I figured out that there are different kinds of friendship. The M & T one is… based on mutual love of Christ and trust of one another, without face-to-face contact–almost like internet friendships.

I’d promoted Aelred over M & T, but that misses the point. Aelred lives out a model of philosophical friendship, where mutual pursuit of truth binds people together over distance and time. I think Aelred has a lot of insights that are especially applicable to people whose closest friends aren’t Christian. He talks about friendship that isn’t explicitly, necessarily, centered on Christ, whereas Maurice and Therese are entirely about their common purpose in Christ.

Morrissey: So yeah, I dissed You Are the Quarry, and I was right. It’s frequently awful.

But I didn’t realize that some parts of it are addictive. I’d say tracks 2 through 10 or 11 are… the kind of thing I end up listening to a lot, whether or not I like it. It isn’t anywhere near the artistic achievement of Ringleader of the Tormentors, much more like the pop interest of Viva Hate and Your Arsenal. But I was wrong to suggest that Southpaw Grammar was better–it’s desperately boring, and I can’t imagine listening to it for fun–and I’ll also say that Vauxhall and I is good enough, though not great. I really like it. The only truly great Morrissey album is Ringleader, though the early ones come close.

I think I will go back to listening to “You Have Killed Me” now.