Jon Stewart and Avoiding a Narrow Mind

Jon Stewart and Avoiding a Narrow Mind February 3, 2015

By Dr. Kara Powell 

This post is an authorized republication of a post that originally appearing on the Fuller Youth Institute’s blog. A special thank you to Kara Powell, Brad Griffin, and the FYI team. To see the original, click here.


“Leadership begins with listening.”

This mantra, provided by Dr. Scott Cormode here at Fuller Seminary, quickly becomes one of the backbones of our Sticky Faith Cohorts. In order to train congregations in building Sticky Faith changes, we help them understand not only what to change, but how to bring about that change. Leaders quickly learn that listening to others (students, parents, volunteers, congregation members) is a key first step in changing a church culture.

That’s why I was especially intrigued with Jon Stewart’s interview with Cass Sunstein, a faculty member at Harvard. In research described in Sunstein’s book, Wiser, Sunstein studied the effect of spending time with like-minded people. For instance, he examined somewhat “liberal” folks in Boulder, Colorado who spent time only with others who were similarly “liberal,” and replicated the same analysis with more “conservative” folks in Colorado Springs.

His finding: A short discussion with like-minded people made liberals more liberal, and conservatives more conservative. This “echo chamber” effect has been demonstrated in multiple settings when similarly-minded men and women spend time with each other.

How does this relate to leadership and changing church culture?

If we’re only spending time with people who are like us—or share our viewpoints—we become closed to fresh perspectives. We become more firmly stuck in our ideological ruts, making it harder to leave those ruts even when and if we eventually want to.

Seeing this interview has made me ask myself a handful of questions:

1. How much time am I spending interacting with people, and media, who have different political viewpoints than me? One of my close friends listens on the radio to NPR and watches Fox News as her attempt for bipartisan information. I probably am not capable of that sort of stretching, but how much am I listening to contradictory political views?

2. How much am I listening to people in different socio-economic statuses?

3. How much am I learning from and interacting with folks from different ethnicities or cultures than me?

4. As I seek to make change at Fuller or in my own church, how am I doing at seeking out different viewpoints?

Of these 4 questions, I feel good about 2 of my answers, and not-so-good about the other 2.

How do you try to love, listen, and learn from folks who are different than you?


Kara Powell, PhD, is the Executive Director of the Fuller Youth Institute and a faculty member at Fuller Theological Seminary. Named by Christianity Today as one of “50 Women to Watch”, Kara serves as an adviser to Youth Specialties and also speaks regularly at parenting and leadership conferences.  Kara is the author or co-author of a number of books including The Sticky Faith Guide for Your FamilySticky Faith CurriculumCan I Ask That?Deep Justice JourneysEssential LeadershipDeep Justice in a Broken WorldDeep Ministry in a Shallow World, and the Good Sex Youth Ministry Curriculum. You can follow her at @KaraPowellFYI.

Follow Fuller Seminary on Twitter at @fullerseminary.


Browse Our Archives