To ban or not to ban

To ban or not to ban

That is the question. . . .I think it’s good for people to hear from those who disagree with them. I believe in freedom of expression and freedom of conversation. Contrary to what some of you realize, I have banned people from this blog, those who kept throwing in racist comments or obscene language. Some of you have asked me to ban different commenters for being offensive in various ways. I have sometimes admonished the offenders, but I have resisted blocking them from participating in the discussions. But now I have heard in one of the comments (somewhere past 400 in the “Where are the Lutherans” thread) a new consideration. Some commenters, it was said, bring out the worst in some of you, to the point of making you sin in your reactions. That frames the issue differently, not in terms of rules but in effect, not focusing on a person’s misbehavior in isolation but on the harm it does to others, thinking in terms not of abstractions but in love of neighbor.

So what do you think? Should I ban participants in this blog with greater frequency? Are any of you being harmed morally or spiritually by anyone who comments here (no names need be mentioned)? Not just offended but tempted to uncharitable thoughts and emotions?

We really do have a kind of community here, so I take seriously what you think. Can we take a vote?

"And speaking of articles we ran across this morning, here's one for Dr. Veith and ..."

How Religion Can Be Growing and ..."
"Oh, yeah, Pressler. Shocking is the word."

How Religion Can Be Growing and ..."
"Speaking of Southern Baptists I found this very recent article by David French shocking. https://www.bishop-accountability.org/2026/05/i-dont-think-you-can-even-call-this-hypocrisy/"

How Religion Can Be Growing and ..."
"What Jesus means is determined by what He says. The debate is over how to ..."

Ascension Day and the Sacraments

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


TAKE THE
Religious Wisdom Quiz

What instrument did David play?

Select your answer to see how you score.