Tolerance vs. other liberties?

Tolerance vs. other liberties? April 20, 2015

The University of Michigan was going to screen the Academy-Award-nominated American Sniper, but then cancelled it when students launched a petition claiming the movie was intolerant of Muslims.  But then other students launched a counter-petition saying that the university should show the movie in the name of artistic liberty and the freedom of expression.  Whereupon the university cancelled its cancellation and agreed to show the movie after all.

But the incident shows that the principle of tolerance above all can be used for many different purposes.  A consensus seems to be emerging that tolerance should trump religious liberty.  Might the demand for tolerance also be used to trump other civil liberties?

Freedom of Speech is arguably already muted by speech codes.  I suspect that we need to formally and legally work out the boundaries between tolerance and civil liberties.  Any ideas about how to draw those lines?

From University of Michigan won’t cancel ‘American Sniper’ –

The University of Michigan has decided to proceed with a screening of the film “American Sniper” despite objections from some students.More than 200 students signed a petition asking the school not to show the movie as part of UMix, a series of social events the university stages for students.

Bradley Cooper was nominated for an Oscar for his portrayal of Chris Kyle, a Navy SEAL and the most lethal sniper in U.S. military history. Kyle was fatally shot at a Texas shooting range in 2013.Some students believed the movie’s depiction of the Iraq War reflected negatively on the Middle East and people from that region.

Michigan’s Detroit metropolitan area is home to the nation’s largest Arab-American population.But there was a backlash to the decision to yank the movie, and a counter-petition asked school officials to reconsider.On Wednesday, E. Royster Harper, University of Michigan’s vice president for student life, said in a statement that “It was a mistake to cancel the showing of the movie ‘American Sniper’ on campus as part of a social event for students” and that the show will go on.

“The initial decision to cancel the movie was not consistent with the high value the University of Michigan places on freedom of expression and our respect for the right of students to make their own choices in such matters,” the statement said.


Browse Our Archives