What Is So Wonderful about Lutheran Worship

What Is So Wonderful about Lutheran Worship April 14, 2020

Yesterday we blogged about Joy Pullman’s lament over the loss of corporate worship, along with her complaints about government overreach in shutting churches down.  To launch this blog’s temporary cessation from all-coronavirus-all-the-time coverage, I want to highlight something else she said, why she finds the worship in the Lutheran church that she has converted to so wonderful.

What Pullman, the executive editor of The Federalist, says, of course, applies to all churches whose worship follows the historic liturgy.  But she is referring specifically to Lutherans worship, though some from that tradition take what they have had for granted and, inexplicably, want to worship like other contemporary Christians instead.  Her words should help life-long Lutherans appreciate what they have been doing every Sunday, and they capture well what I have so much appreciated as a fellow Lutheran convert.

From Joy Pullman, They Can Keep Us from Holy Week, but Nothing Can Stop Easter in The Federalist:

Our church and orders of service are precious to me, and our congregation. The things our pastors say, do, and wear are have been cultivated over centuries. We worship this way on purpose. Everything has a meaning, and has been carefully selected, debated among clergy and lay people, and thoughtfully placed.

Unlike the kinds of evangelical churches I grew up in, nothing in our services are random, or the production of one person, one church, one pastor, or locality. It is comprehensive, ordered, painstakingly thought through, the production of the whole church over centuries. It’s not just this way for some general service; this theological craftsmanship envelops the entire church year. Every Sunday and season has its place in an orchestrated tapestry. These centuries of labored love culminate in our highest holy days, this week.

Like Christians have for hundreds, thousands of years, our congregation is used to gathering and carrying out special, very specific, highly meaningful, and carefully ordered scripture readings, prayers, hymns, and services. They are rituals created by centuries of tradition, and thus exceedingly rich.

This humbling before our ancestors in the faith going back to the great apostles is a chief reason I left rootless evangelicalism to become Lutheran, which I consider catholic the way Catholics ought to be. I wanted to belong to something bigger and better than myself and my age. Something outside myself that instructs, shapes, and bends me, rather than being small and petty enough for me to shape and bend as I will. That’s what transcendence means.

It is also what respect and reverence mean: Not trashing one’s inheritance for ignorant and temporary comfort. This inheritance delivers what I need so badly — more than anything else, in fact. Christ’s own body and blood come to me as He did: physically. Incarnated. Embodied. The manner in which we take God himself into our own bodies matters, and that we do so is necessary to our faith and eternal life. My religion teaches this, and I believe it.


Photo credit:  “Typical Eucharist in an LCMS Church” by self – self, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikipedia



"It doesn't take much in the way of failures for people to doubt the whole ..."

Nudge vs. Mandate
"Freeman, your opening sentence reveals how little you actually know about Lutheran teachings. One, we ..."

How Should Churches Respond to Cultural ..."
"They did point to their s*xual ethics, but they were also known for their charity. ..."

How Should Churches Respond to Cultural ..."
"As Francis Urquhart used to say "You might very well think that; I couldn't possibly ..."

Nudge vs. Mandate

Browse Our Archives