DISCUSSION: Immigration

DISCUSSION: Immigration May 19, 2023

A major issue today is immigration, especially as the COVID-era provision expires and we face the prospect of a new mass surge across the border.

On the one hand, we are a nation of immigrants.  Nearly all of us or our ancestors, except for members of Native American tribes, came from somewhere else.  The words on the Statue of Liberty express one of our traditional values:  “Give me your huddled masses yearning to be free.”

On the other hand, surely immigration is something the government should control and regulate, as it did in the previous migrations that most of our ancestors were part of.  Every nation has to control its borders, or borders are meaningless.  And those who sneak in and are here unlawfully are behaving illegally.

I would say that the huge number of people who want to come to America defies the leftist portrayal of this country as a white supremacist hell hole.  These folks see the U.S.A. as a land of freedom and opportunity that is far better than where they came from.

Both the left and the right are calling for immigration reform, but no one can agree what that should look like.

What do you think?

"It's a mistake to take anything Biden or Trump say as sincere moral stances rather ..."

Trump’s Abortion Policy
"That's an imposition of liberal's primitive sense of morality. Conservatives hold a morality that is ..."

Trump’s Abortion Policy
"Yes, morality plays a role in our reasoning. But one risk is the temptation to ..."

Trump’s Abortion Policy
"That won't stop them from trying to make that analogy, though. Read the pro-secessionist rhetoric ..."

Trump’s Abortion Policy

Browse Our Archives