The problem of pleasure

The problem of pleasure

The Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup post made me recall a C. S. Lewis quip, which together formed this thought:

If the problem of pain is a difficult philosophical and theological problem–how could a just God allow the existence of so much pain in the world?–surely there must also be an equally difficult problem of pleasure: How could a just God allow the existence of so much pleasure in the world?

What does it mean that God gave us our senses, that He created colors and made us to perceive flavors (such as chocolate and peanut butter, sweetness and savoriness), a universe filled with beauty, a course of ordinary life filled with so many satisfactions? Yes, we also experience pain, but if this is supposed to be a vale of soul building, shouldn’t our lives be harder than they usually are? Why does He insist on being so good to us?

"The reference to St Ambrose in the post leads me to mention an historical oddity. ..."

The Impact of St. Augustine
"DakotaLutheran is right. If you go to the bottom of the Patheos home page, you'll ..."

The Impact of St. Augustine
"There's a lot here, especially regarding what various things mean, not just whatever you or ..."

The Impact of St. Augustine
"That may be a type of work around, but it is not a solution. A ..."

The Impact of St. Augustine

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


TAKE THE
Religious Wisdom Quiz

Who said, "Father, I have sinned against heaven and against you"?

Select your answer to see how you score.