Walking Toward Forgiveness

Walking Toward Forgiveness January 24, 2014

Outside our trailer park, a set of railroad tracks ran from east to west, dividing us from the police station that sat half a mile down the road. When you drove over the tracks, and felt the car pull itself over the split asphalt, it seemed like you were being locked in or released, depending on which way you were driving.

I used to walk along the tracks at dusk, singing and talking to myself, the fields stretching westward behind me as the sun sank behind the Walgreens. I practiced lines for my high school plays; I imagined what it would be like to walk with whichever boy at school I liked at the time. I tried to keep myself occupied as long as I could, tried to fill my mind with anything besides the dull dread that I knew would be waiting for me once I got back home.

What is poignant about this scene is that it is one of the few memories I have where the sensory detail is so vivid—I have bits of images, movements, but it is hard to place whole memories. I know that so much of what happened has been buried deep within me, and when something surfaces, I have to try to catch as much as I can.

What I remember, mostly, is walking: walking to the curb to meet the police officer before my mother’s boyfriend knew I had called; walking my mother to her bed with her lips against my ear, drunk and sorry and heaving sobs so big that I almost lost my grip on her shoulder. Walking in the fiery shafts of light that cut across the tracks, my voice carrying over the cornfields: But it wouldn’t be make believe / if you believed in me.

Memory is, to me, one of the heaviest burdens you carry when you come from a family like mine. Even the good memories are burdens; they always cast a wistful shadow, make you think about what things could have been like, what things might have been.

And what I’ve heard from others, those who come from families like mine, and those who don’t, is that a sure way to release the burden of these memories, is to forgive.

I know that to not forgive is not an option; I am a Christian, and forgiveness is the central tenant, the lynchpin, the way through the eye of the needle.

But there is something in the idea of forgiveness that, at this point in my life, makes me nauseous.

It isn’t that I don’t want to forgive my parents for the things that have happened. I’ve told them that I forgive them, many times over, but the memories remain. Truth be told, the same things keep on happening. New memories emerge. And as I make my way through marriage and parenthood, I find myself locked in a perpetual mode of defense, my gut and throat tightening whenever the topic comes up.

I suppose it’s the finality of it—if I say that I forgive, there are no more grounds for me to be suspicious or wary of the loved ones who have hurt me so deeply. It’s done, over, the past belonging to the past, and the future a blank slate that I somehow owe to the ones that hurt my siblings and me so deeply. “How wonderful it must be,” I’ve heard, “to forgive and leave all that behind you.”

But when the ones I’m supposed to forgive continue to present real and present danger to me and my loved ones—when my mother’s insistence on another visit to our home leaves me breathless and weeping in our armchair—it doesn’t seem right.

And neither does the view of forgiveness as a way to free myself from these memories. “Do it for you,” I’ve also heard, and while I get that letting my mother and father off the hook could create some distance, it also seems to fall short of the ones forgiveness is intended for, both victim and perpetrator.

In Patty Griffin’s song “Forgiveness,” there is a line that catches my throat each time I hear it: We are calling for help tonight / on a thin phone line.

That’s what my whole childhood felt like: a call for help, a repeated dialing of the phone, the police leaving and my mother’s boyfriend staying, my mother walking out the door to get to the bar at its opening, her figure diminishing as I watched from the door. I walked the line of railroad ties and hoped that something would open up to us, let us out, set us free from the terror and ache we knew.

What it comes down to, I think, is that forgiveness is neither altar call nor personal mantra, but a reality to be lived into, something that calls out to us from the edges of what we know and feel and believe. It is the desire and the move to love, and what I know is this: that I love my family fiercely and deeply. There is nothing I want more than the ease other families share, the comfort of trust and the freedom of letting go.

But there is a great gap fixed between that desire and the present reality, the ongoing difficulties that my family presents, the continual unfolding of memories, my parents’ inability to seek forgiveness themselves, their limitations and their own fixations on what was robbed from them too large to shake off.

How will the gap be bridged? I have no idea. I spent my twenties mourning the childhood I had and looking for ways to make my life new. And as my life has turned, the cycle of mourning continues: my siblings’ own memories, splintered as mine, piece themselves together, and we are left sobbing and shaking and unable to sleep at night.

And in the sleeplessness, I nurse my son. He eats and returns to sleep, his body a sturdy weight against my shoulder, a buoy, a promise, the morning light rising in the window, the Wyoming sky stretching over us, wide and open.

Allison Backous Troy teaches at Kuyper College in Grand Rapids, Michigan, and is the creative writing editor for The Other Journal. She graduated from the Seattle Pacific University’s Master of Fine Arts in Creative Writing program in 2009.

This is Allison Backous Troy’s last regular post for “Good Letters.” We thank her for her beautiful writing and wish her well.


Browse Our Archives

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Alan

    A beautifully heartfelt piece.

  • I experienced the same kind of conflicts you described, and spent many years trying to reconcile the idea of forgiveness with acceptance. The more I tried, the more the memories of betrayal had an absolute grip over my emotional life. Finally, I had to give up on the idea because it was destroying me. I cannot speak for you, but from my own experience, I had to reject the people who betrayed me, and at the same time, forgive them, and forgive myself, too, in a sense. I realized the guilt I felt in rejecting them was not real. I rely on the words of Jesus, where he says the gospel will separate families and cause divisions, and we must be ready to leave father and mother, brother and sister. Jesus forgives unconditionally, yet he will reject many who say they love him. I concluded that it is a matter of conscience to determine whether true reconciliation is possible or not. Now, I have my life back. I’m learning to be happy again. I’m not haunted by the nightmares and the wishful thinking. I’m no longer making myself physically ill with those toxic emotions. I found that the only way to truly forgive some people is to cut them off and let them go. The essence of forgiveness is to be at peace with oneself about another person. A false reconciliation, or false promises of an impossible one, denies you that peace.

    • Monica Ruth Brands

      Agree, “it is a matter of conscience whether true reconciliation is possible or not.” “We must be ready to leave father and mother, brother and sister” – that’s a line that comes to my mind a lot – if redemption is calling us into new creation with Christ, we simply have to let go of those who don’t want us to experience resurrection life. Not with hard feelings, or hatred, with love, and prayers for them to someday experience it as well.

  • Monica Ruth Brands

    Allison, this is one of the best pieces on the limits of forgiveness that I’ve read. I have found for my emotional sanity I have no choice but to maintain a healthy distance, but I don’t really doubt that I have “really” forgiven. Even when I see some members of my family, I have to keep myself detached, invulnerable, not open myself up to being hurt. Forgiveness is one thing, but reconciliation is about trust, and trust is something that has to be earned again.

    • Monica Ruth Brands

      Maybe that’s a copout, I suppose that forgiveness also opens up a space in the heart to love and be loved by the one you’ve forgiven instead of making them earn your trust — but I’m trying to say that when you are dealing with someone who can’t help but abuse, you have to in some way make yourself protected from the inevitability of their abuse. Moments of connection and love are something I hold on to, but I don’t try to make those moments redefine the entire relationship. Those moments are possible because of forgiveness, but also something I have to latch onto out of a background of necessary distance, and leave all expectations at the door when I have to see someone I do not trust.