I’ve listened to Paul Everett’s voice come through a prison phone line in Florida…steady, unbroken, unadorned. He sounds like a man who has made peace with who he is, but not with the lie that put him in a cage. That lie has cost him more than twenty years of his life. Now the state of Florida is preparing to end what remains.
This article is based on conversations that I had with him about what really happened to Kelli Bailey…conversations he wanted shared. Every detail in this article comes straight from Paul. I also spent time verifying key facts from his account with those closest to him. This is what they all collectively know to be true.
The Truth
Paul Everett is innocent.
He did not kill Kelli Bailey. The man who did…Jared Farmer…has lived freely for more than two decades while Everett waits on death row for a crime that is not his. If nothing intervenes, the state will strap an innocent man to a gurney, slide needles into his veins and call it justice. It will not be justice. It will be murder.
Childhood in Fort Payne
Everett grew up in Fort Payne, Alabama, a small town that once called itself the sock capital of the world. Hosiery mills dotted the landscape. People worked hard and knew one another. He came from a big family…seven siblings, two parents who were present. They weren’t rich, but they were stable. The kind of childhood that only reveals its goodness after it’s gone.
Drugs arrived early. Marijuana in middle school. Daily use by fourteen. Meth by seventeen. Once meth took hold, it reorganized everything. Addiction became routine, as ordinary as breathing.
Then the mills collapsed. Jobs disappeared. The deals Paul Everett’s father had trusted fell apart. The ground gave way beneath the family, and Paul…still a teenager…did what desperate kids do. He hustled. He dropped out of school at sixteen. He cycled in and out of jail for petty, nonviolent offenses: addiction crimes, poverty crimes, the predictable wreckage of a young life with no footing.
There is nothing in Paul Everett’s past that points toward violence. No assaults. No cruelty. No pattern that would make sense of what the state later accused him of. Just a young man burning his own life down and knowing it.
Paul Everett’s Search for a New Beginning
By 2001, Paul Everett was twenty-two and trying to escape the gravity of everything he’d become. He wanted out…out of meth, out of Fort Payne, out of the cycle. He had a girlfriend back home and a fragile hope that something like stability might still be possible.
That was when linking up with Jared Farmer offered a way out. Panama City, Florida. Connections. Money. Weed instead of meth. A fresh start. It sounded like a rescue. It wasn’t.
Panama City turned out to be a lie. Farmer had no real network, just small-time dealers and meth users whose paranoia ran hot. Paul Everett realized quickly that there was no future there and decided to leave. He planned to give it a few days and head back to Alabama.
Before he did, he went jogging.
That’s when he met her.
The Woman He Knew as Angel
She was watering plants in late October…an odd detail that stuck with him. They talked. She knew Chattanooga. She knew the Fort Payne area. Familiar geography turned into familiarity. Before they parted, she invited him back for dinner.
She told him her name was Angel.
Paul Everett came back that night. Steak on the stove. Baked potatoes. Easy conversation. Sex. He left before dawn. And then he came back again. And again.
For weeks.
They weren’t confessing their souls to one another, but they were together often. She cooked for him. They slept in the same bed. She mentioned a complicated situation with a husband. Paul Everett didn’t push.
She never told him her real name.
Angel was Kelli Bailey.
Paul Everett would not learn that until she was dead.
The Paranoia That Surrounded Paul Everett
As Paul Everett spent his nights with Kelli, meth paranoia was fermenting around them. Two men known as Bubba and Chico became convinced she was a cop. She snooped. Checked mailboxes. Wandered yards. To minds warped by meth, that was enough.
Then they noticed Paul Everett. The outsider. The man from Alabama who was always with her.
Paul Everett tried to calm things down. He told them she wasn’t a threat. That only made it worse. Defending her made him suspect too.
Everything spiraled.
The Night That Changed His Life Forever
On the night of November 1, 2001, Jared Farmer went to Kelli Bailey’s house. That fact alone should have mattered. It didn’t.
A confrontation broke out. Violence followed. And here is what the jury never heard: Kelli Bailey confronted the intruders. What happened next was chaotic and brutal. Farmer assaulted the woman he had been seeing for weeks. The situation collapsed into something he could not control.
So Paul Everett did the one thing that separates him from her killers.
He left…believing that his absence would lead to things calming down.
When Paul Everett walked out of that house, Kelli Bailey was still alive. Injured. On the floor. But alive.
Paul Everett did not kill her.
The men who stayed behind did.
The Threats That Silenced Paul Everett
What followed was silence enforced by fear. Paul Everett was warned. His family could be reached. His father could be hurt. If he told the truth about Jared Farmer, the consequences would not stop with him.
When police finally questioned Paul Everett, terror shaped his words. He protected Farmer. He buried the truth. Those frightened, coerced statements became the spine of the state’s case.
The Trial That Failed Paul Everett
At trial, the truth never entered the room. Jared Farmer never testified. Bubba never testified. Chico never testified. The jury never heard about paranoia, threats or multiple perpetrators. They never heard that Paul Everett and Kelli had been in a relationship for weeks. The prosecution needed him to be a stranger, a burglar, an easy villain.
The trial was brief—shockingly brief for a capital case. The defense aimed to avoid execution, not to prove innocence. The jury, denied the truth, sentenced an innocent man to die.
This all happened in the shadow of September 11. The country wasn’t paying attention. The case disappeared. Paul Everett went to death row at twenty-two.
He is forty-six now (he’ll turn forty-seven on February 11).
More than half his life gone.
Two Mothers, One Lie
When Paul Everett talks about the verdict, he talks about two mothers—his own and Kelli Bailey’s. One watches the state prepare to kill her innocent son. The other believes her daughter’s killer was punished.
Both were lied to.
Paul Everett Deserves Justice
Paul Everett is innocent. Jared Farmer killed Kelli Bailey. The state of Florida has it backwards, and if it proceeds, it will commit an irreversible atrocity to protect a lie.
Paul Everett walked out of that house while Kelli Bailey was still alive. That truth has been buried for more than twenty years.
It’s time to dig it up.
Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In