Doubt, Demoralization, and the Company You Keep

Doubt, Demoralization, and the Company You Keep November 29, 2017

More and more of my Catholic friends are struggling to stay Catholic.  They are demoralized and discouraged.  They see many people who claim to be faithful Catholics, but who:

  • Show blatant indifference to the suffering of others.
  • Defend behavior that is utterly contrary to the faith.
  • Carve out reasons why the Church doesn’t really teach what she plainly teaches.
  • Take advantage of the goodwill of fellow Catholics.
  • Consider anyone who isn’t of “their tribe” to be worthy of spite and contempt.
  • Turn the cold shoulder on people earnestly struggling to come deeper into the faith, but who aren’t all the way there yet.

The list could go on.  This isn’t even about the abuse crisis.  This is about people who are supposed to know better, and who claim to know better, and who have set themselves up as “The Good Catholics” behaving in ways that are simply not Catholic.

Here’s a sample conversation from a friend’s social-media account:

Demoralized Friend: I feel like all the Catholics I know are complete jerks who don’t care anything about the human person, and just want you to shut up and slap a Jesus sticker on all their bad behavior.

Atheist Friend: This is why I’m an atheist.


Atheist Friend:  Weirdly, I don’t find that to be a very compelling argument for the faith.

Catholic Jerk Friend: Yo Demoralized Catholic Friend!  God has a message for you, too: QUIT WHINING, WHINER.

Atheist Friend:  Hey, DF, I’m sorry you’ve got such jerky Catholic friends.  Wanna go out for drinks sometime?

And of course into all this, Demoralized Friend is fed a steady stream of articles from nasty jerkish Professional Catholics, carefully designed to make sure that when she kicks up her feet after a long day of dealing in person with nasty jerkish Catholics, she can log onto the internet and find yet more.

This is not the Catholic faith.

This is an example of people proving why bad behavior is not what God wants for you.

People are Jerks

The fact that Catholics do behave badly is literally an article of our faith.  We stand up at every Mass and publically declare it.  But what we always, always, insist is this: You aren’t meant to be like this.

Being a stupid jerk is not what God wants for you.  It is not what will make you happy, either in this life or the next.  So when instead of exalting Jesus Christ you exalt your asinine behavior, you have parted ways with the narrow road.

Pick Your Jerks Carefully

Catholic friends, there is such a thing as too much open-mindedness.

Will all your friends in this life be flawed persons in need of compassion and forgiveness and a periodic kick in the rear?  Yes they will.

But you must choose friends who, despite their flaws, help you grow in your faith.

I don’t know who those people are for you.  Look around.  Check under the couch cushions and behind corners, and don’t be afraid to find the people who encourage you and build up your faith in weird places.

You don’t have to read articles by people who are stupid jerks.  You don’t have to watch TV shows featuring stupid jerks.  You don’t have to be on the committee of Jerky Jerks Promoting Jerkiness.   You may remove these people from your friends list, make other plans for the holidays, and decline to vote for them in the next election.

God did not appoint you Minister of Asinine Behavior, responsible for keeping up with the doings of  every stupid, selfish, craven blight of an excuse for a Catholic.

Get a New Hobby

There is a certain amount of forbearance and forgiveness that God is calling on you to exercise.

That amount is plenty.

It is an act of pride — the deadly-sin sort of pride — to presume you are such a wellspring of the depths of mercy that you, personally, don’t need any of the boundaries that other mere mortals require.

You are human.  You are limited.  You are frail.

You get kicked around enough just enduring those things which can’t be avoided.  Don’t go seeking out more.  Find something else to do that takes your mind off the evil people as much as you can possibly  manage.

God bless you.

Don’t give up on God.  God loves you.  God wants you to know Him, and delight in Him, and find rest in Him.

Don’t settle for hucksters selling Jesus-brand loads of venomous nonsense.  Insist on the real thing, brought to you by the Father, Son & Holy Spirit, amen.

Madonna of the Rosary, by Caravaggio (of course). Public Domain, via Wikimedia.




Browse Our Archives