“aha” moments: a pastor tells his story (15): anonymous

“aha” moments: a pastor tells his story (15): anonymous August 11, 2014

silloueteI have long thought that the #1 factor in bringing about theological change is that “life happens”–new experiences that cannot be held in old containers.

Many (but not all) of the “aha” moments posted thus far, including my own, have centered on some moments of intellectual clarity concerning Scripture that led to rethinking one’s view of the Bible, faith, and life.

For others, like today’s anonymous author, “aha” moments originate in painful personal experiences that drive one to go back and re-examine one’s theology.

I’m sure many readers will resonate with the author’s story–it is tragically common–and you will see the wisdom of his request to remain anonymous. I honor the author for wanting to tell his story and am privileged that he asked if he could post it as part of this series.


I am a pastor. I wish I had been a scholar and could have gotten my a-ha on with study and consideration. My a-ha, sadly, began with oh-no.

From the time I was a teenager I was taught that the Bible was “the Maker’s Manufacturer’s Instruction Manual.” I remember my parents having a sign that read: “God said it, I believe it, That settles it” in our car.

I was taught that the Bible “was” God’s Word and that was very different than the Bible “containing” God’s Word.

It was made obvious that everything in the Bible could be supported by everything else in the Bible without one single contradiction.

I was taught that everything needed a chapter and verse and then you were golden.

It was with the wooden-literalism of what is today being called Biblicism that I was taught to:

Follow exactly, the Matthew 18 model of confrontation — being sure to get the math exactly right (just two, take two, between two and three, etc.) “Have you Matthew 18’d them yet?”

Keep women out of the pastorate as they were to keep silent in church (because only the modern-day pastoral vocation was in mind in 1 Timothy 2:12) and we needed them in Sunday School, up through Junior High, anyway.

Always have all the children in all the worship services, per Matthew 19:14 “let the little children come to me, and do not hinder them.”

Stop and unleash all bad thoughts I’d had about a person to them and ask for forgiveness (Matthew 5:23 “If you are offering your gift at the altar and there remember that your brother has something against you…) I was also taught that only Catholics had altars and they weren’t Christians.

Demand head coverings for women (1 Corinthians 11:6, If a woman does not cover her head, she should have her hair cut off; and if it is a disgrace for a woman to have her hair cut or shaved off, she should cover her head.) Okay, we did eventually find a workaround for that one.

Oh, and of course, to not entertain an accusation against an elder unless it is brought by two or three witnesses. (1 Timothy 5:19 says: Do not.)

I was taught not to be a liberal, to have a high view of Scripture, and to stay off of slopes that were slippery by sticking with those who were right and taking the Bible seriously because they were taking it literally.

In our church there was a lady who brought an accusation, of sorts, about an elder. She had an uneasy feeling about him that she couldn’t identify. I told her she should talk to him as they were family friends. We prayed. She did. We Matthew 18’d him.

She returned to me much later with the same feeling, indicating that it was a feeling she had about him with my young daughter. We prayed. I went to him.

No one else had said a word, so when the woman returned much later, and the two of us prayed, and then went to him, and then to he and his wife, I was staying well within 1 Timothy 5.

Then the two of us with another elder prayed, and went to him when she came to me the next time. She couldn’t identify the problem, and though some instances could be seen where there wasn’t always the greatest maturity being shown by this man, there was nothing suspect.

No one was bringing a specific accusation against this guy, and up until this time only one woman had a weird feeling. We kept 1 Timothy 5:19 in clear view.

Over time, as her feelings and paranoia increased (to the point that she came to believe she might even be dealing with mental illness), things began to change and the elder-in-question’s behavior became very strange and erratic. In a tumultuous series of events it came out that the man had been molesting my daughter for several years.

Oh-no. Actually, far, far worse than that.

In an instant, those (years now of the) woman’s suspicions came into complete clarity. In an instant, the Bible, and the God of the Bible, came crumbling down around me. 1 Timothy hadn’t righteously protected us; my literalizing of it had, instead, destroyed.

At first, the only thing that made any sense was working to protect my daughter, my family, and then the church. It was oh-no for years, and we all did the best we could. That was the only important thing to begin with and God’s graciousness, over time, did, and has done much healing and restoration.

But, though a lesser issue for me at the time however significant, I didn’t completely realize in those days that God had, in a sense, died to me.

Well, at least the God I thought I knew, and my understanding of the Bible He had given me had died.

The God I had known, and the Bible I had were somehow magical, and faithful adherence to them, alongside the certain and truly faithful, could never have brought about this result— even though I was told by several that this was God’s will for my daughter, and that she needed this for her discipleship. I think they needed to be certain about something.

Fortunately, when I came to the end of myself in all this, I somehow still knew one thing “Jesus Christ and him crucified.” The oh-no was terrifying and tragic. But it was also watershed, and gave birth to a-ha.

Backtracking from 1 Timothy 5:19 — because of pastoral experience and not because of scholarly consideration — I began to divest myself of everything I thought I had known about the Bible. It was like a big reset button had been hit.

The underlying programming was there, Jesus and him crucified, but otherwise the hard drive had been wiped clean. It wasn’t easy as I remained a teaching pastor during the entire time.

Along the way I uncovered multiples of untruths purported as absolute truth, and in some cases flat out fabrications of facts by noted scholars, apologists and pastors, with the supposed intent of keeping me safe from the slippery slope of liberalism and disbelief.

When I ran into some of those that happened to bring my former university under fire, I returned to campus after many years to talk with a faculty member about his less-than-literal Genesis views. It was a warm day, during summer break, and this professor — whom I had never met before — spent more than five hours with me to talk me through what he really believed, what he contended the Scriptures are, and what the university held to.

I discovered there really were other honest ways to read the Bible. I walked away from that meeting knowing that one of the hell-bound liberal Bible scholars I had been warned about for years, was in every right and best way, my brother in Christ.

Oh-no, had progressed to a-ha, and finally, climatically became A-HA! I felt like the little Who named JoJo, in “Horton Hears a Who” who finally discovers he can YOPP!

In the face of great tragedy, I remain thankful for Paul’s example and that I too resolved to know nothing except a crucified Jesus. Those events are now many years in the past. My family and congregation continue to heal, and my daughter has married and even given me grandchildren.

And, I am thankful for the fruit of the trauma, even if I could never be thankful for the trauma itself. Which, yes, means I don’t think 1 Thessalonians 5:18 means what I was once taught it meant.

"I think you're arguing with what I'm not saying. I'm not saying there are no ..."

the best defense of the Christian ..."
"Don't you have one? Or do you just want to read it twice?"

we have lift off…my new website ..."
"Ooh yes. Free copy of 'Inspiration and Incarnation'?"

we have lift off…my new website ..."
"My first comment. You should get a prize or something."

we have lift off…my new website ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Evelyn

    Thank you for sharing this difficult aha process in such a grace-filled way.

  • Daniel Fisher

    This is a horrific experience for anyone, and it is courageous to share. When things like this happen in a church setting in particular, it can so deeply undermine any sense of the security and safe place that the church is supposed to be.

    Now, given how personal a story this is, I am reluctant to offer a critique, but I do feel compelled to make this observation: I am not sure how following a strictly literal interpretation of I Timothy 5:19 contributed to the outcome in a significant way – In my position I have counseled dozens of individuals (both male and female) that had been sexually molested as children – and sadly a situation like the one described above is very common, where for years very few if any overt signs were present – especially when the perpetrator is a close friend or family member – sometimes nothing more than perhaps one person just having a “funny feeling,” but little that would have given the family, police, or Child Services any reason or warrant for further investigation.

    Now, this pastor may be blaming himself that ITim5:19 made him blind to something that he may have been able to have seen earlier, or bound him from taking more drastic action, had he not been trying to strictly follow the letter of that law, and granted, that may well be – but for what it is worth, my own counseling experience suggests it is far more complex. If the person in question had been a deacon, or a Sunday School Volunteer, or another close friend of the family, ITim5:19 would not have had any influence – but given this scenario, would most pastors consider making some charge against anyone in their congregation (elder or not), and calling the police, based purely on the “funny feeling” of a single parishioner who worried it may be her own mental health? I see very little likelihood that things might have gone significantly different if the perpetrator in this case had not been an elder but just another loved and respected member of the congregation – perhaps, perhaps, it may have been uncovered a bit earlier – but everything I’ve seen in my own ministry suggests it might well have been very likely that this still would have occurred, and possibly for just as long. All of the dozens of people I have talked with who were abused for years – many who grew up in Christian/churchgoing families – none of my clients in my own counseling work were abused by an elder/clergyperson…. but the fact that ITim5:19 was not in effect did not keep the abuse from happening for as long as it did.

    Again, I don’t mean to show insensitivity to such a heart-wrenching experience, with all the emotional and personal trauma involved; This truly deserves the fullest sympathy and sensitivity. And I appreciate how such a trauma could make this pastor second guess the theology that he perceived as being part of the contributing environment – but I fear that the strict application of ITim5:19 may not be as significant a factor as presented – extremely similar experiences can (and have) happened to children of liberal clergypersons (one at least that I know) for pastors that have no conviction about applying ITim5:19 in the literal manner described above.

    • Derek

      Great insight. Very well said.

  • Daniel Fisher

    On another note, I very much resonate with your description that “The God I had known, and the Bible I had were somehow magical, and faithful adherence to them, alongside the certain and truly faithful, could never have brought about this result.”

    Your words here should certainly be a wake-up call to those who have the simplistic view that rigidly following a literal and strict life according to the Bible somehow guarantees safety, security, peace, and the lack of any trouble in this present world. Unfortunately, in general, I see those who hold such views to do so out of a desire to have such peace and happiness, rather than out of a desire to embrace the fullness of what the Bible actually presents – I have to wonder if people that hold the “faithfulness guarantees happiness” idea have ever seriously wrestled with the implications of Job, Lamentations, the Psalms of Lament, or practically half of what Jesus said?

    • Anonymous

      Daniel, thank you for your compassion and your thoughts. There is much more to the story, including an entanglement of relationships, positions and other events that are not elaborated on here, for the privacy of the victims in the situation. Your concerns have validity, but much of them, certainly not all, averted by those additional details. I do understand the heart of what you’re expressing, and very much appreciate your insights and am thankful for your sensitivity. Thank you so very much for sharing.

    • Derek

      Daniel, you better be in some form of ministry. We need more people like you.

  • Ron

    This very moving and powerful theme (where is God when a child is being sexually abused?) is capably explored in the novel entitled “The Shack.”

    • WhatChrisLikes

      A variation on that theme is explored in the science fiction book “The Sparrow” by Mary Doria Russell. I can’t recommend the book enough, whether you like science fiction for world-building, ethical exploration, or just for alien stories.

  • toddh

    “I was told by several that this was God’s will for my daughter, and that she needed this for her discipleship” – unbelievable. You are a good man for not doing something horrible at that point.