Justification and Judgment in Paul

Justification and Judgment in Paul April 27, 2022

Richard Beck has begun a new series on Paul’s theology, after reading (among other things) Gabriele Boccaccini’s book Paul’s Three Paths to Salvation (currently available for only $5 for Kindle!). Here is a taste from Beck’s first post:

Paul thought judgment was imminent. So this time of “holding fast” wasn’t going to be very long. It was a doable proposition. Hang in there, be faithful, the time is short. But as generations have passed, the lag time between justification and judgment has grown. Most of us are “justified by faith” early in life, and we expect to die before the Second Coming. That’s a very long time to “hold fast.” Our moral witness ebbs and flows across the lifespan. And as it does, it brings to our attention those New Testament warnings about falling away. It also raises questions about how effortful this moral journey is. You have to work very hard at it, day in and day out, decade after decade. Which raises the question: Isn’t all this work morphing into a works-based righteousness? Especially when we compare ourselves to believers who are putting in precisely zero work and effort? How, exactly, is justification and sanctification supposed to work? Can those “justified by faith” behave any way they please, for their entire lives, with no consequences? If so, what’s the point of putting in any work at all in following Jesus if none of it matters? Is not faith dead without works? And yet, if we do work hard, and think that work matters before God and will be rewarded by God, are we are not expecting to be judged by our acts of righteousness instead of grace?

We enter here the tempest of questions that have swirled around these issues since Martin Luther. But again, these are our issues, not Paul’s. Paul never had to deal with the theological, moral, and pastoral implications of a delayed parousia.

Click through to Beck’s blog Experimental Theology to read the rest. In his second post in the series he turns to the relationship between Jesus and John the Baptist! I am not sure he comes up with an actual distinction between the two (which doesn’t surprise me). He writes, “Jesus retains John’s vision of a coming judgement…Jesus also teaches, as with John, that this judgment will be focused upon works…It’s difficult to avoid the conclusion that Jesus preached that we will be judged by our deeds on Judgment Day. Both Jesus and John agree on this point…Jesus and John were on the same Second Temple eschatological page.” Read the rest of that post on his blog.

Also related:

Marg Mowczko shares Judith Gundry’s arguments and conclusions about 1 Corinthians 11:2-16

New in Hervormde Teologiese Studies 77/2 (2021): Andries G. van Aarde, “What could Paul have meant by ‘against nature’ (παρὰ φύσιν) as written in Romans 1:26? Striving for the well-being and health of all people.B. J. Oropeza has a new article out in Religions (also open access, just like the previous one I mentioned) about reader competency and Paul’s use of scripture in Romans.

Dr. Yung Suk Kim explains why “Pistis Christou is a bone of contention”and also offers a new translation of 1 Corinthians 12:27.

Dr. Patrick McMurray on his new book Sacrifice, Brotherhood, and the Body: Abraham and the Nations in Romans

Rev. Dr. Jeffrey Frantz argues that Paul was “a First Century Feminist.” Do you agree? Why or why not?

Paul and Pneuma, Justin and Judaism: Introduction

Paul and the Gentile Problem

Rillera’s Myth Busting Busting: Romans 8:3 (2 of 7)

Rillera’s Myth Busting Busting: Galatians 3:13-14 (3 of 7)

Look Inside! Romans: A Theological and Pastoral Commentary

Romans: A Theological and Pastoral Commentary

The Word of the Cross: Reading Paul

Paul: A Multicultural Leader

COVID-19 and Romans 15, Part 1: Problematic Reunions

COVID-19 and Romans 15, Part 2: Pauline Solutions

The Letter to the Romans, by Frederick Dale Bruner

7 Questions with Frederick Dale Bruner

A New Commentary on Romans, by David Garland

Romans 13:1-7 – Translates, Paraphrase, and Notes

Rom 3:21-26 – Translates, Paraphrase, Notes

Look Inside! The Letter to the Romans

What would Righteousness Look Like for Paul’s Original Roman Audience?

N. T. Wright, Galatians (Commentaries for Christian Formation)

A Solution to a Major Anomaly in the Study of Paul: Guest Post by Richard Fellows

Galatians, Evangelical Biblical Theology Commentary

A Basic Lesson from Paul

Paul’s Greatest Idea: Cosmic Transformation

Vice Lists in Paul’s Letters: 5 Observations

Video from the Paul Within Judaism Symposium (HT The Amateur Exegete):

Tom Holland on Paul

Why Paul’s letters are inadequate for understanding salvation

Desire in Paul’s Undisputed Epistles

Pistis christou: whose faith?

Romans 3:22 as snapshot of the gospel

Updated slides on Galatians: Paul’s most urgent letter

In Christ We Trust: Roman Fides and Christian Faith

What was Paul’s Thorn in the Flesh?

‘Paul the Apostle’ by J. Albert Harrill: A Brief Review

Paul had not abandoned Judaism

New book: Paul and Philo on Abraham

Christoph Heilig’s book Paulus als Erzähler? Eine narratologische Perspektive auf die Paulusbriefe is available open access. (HT AWOL)

There are new open access articles that have been published on Paul, empire, and eschatology, the interpretation of the end in Thessalonians, and the power of forgiveness in Ephesians. Also open access is Paul Foster’s article in Expository Times 133/1 (2021)An Apostle Too Radical for the Radical Perspective on Paul.” A book from 1900 by W. G. Rutherford on Romans has been digitized and made available for free online. See also:

St Paul in Asia Minor and Syrian Antioch by E H Plumptre

“Paul within Judaism” Symposium

Richard Beck on J. Louis Martyn’s treatment of Paul’s apocalyptic epistemology

ECR Interview: Dr. Joshua Reno

Nijay and Mike Bird on Romans 12-15 on Two Testaments Podcast

Mike Bird and Nijay Gupta talk about Paul, Philemon, and Onesimus. Mike also blogged about Paul and masculinity (interacting with and highlighting a recent book on the subject), justification by faith, and Paul and supersessionism. See as well Mike’s post on “Romans 8 and the Assurance of God’s Love in Hard Times” and on “the epicenter of Paul’s gospel.” He also shared this video:

New on the Bible Odyssey website: “Romans and the Fate of Israel”

Bill Mounce on giving credit in Romans, the word γάρ in Romans 12:3, the letter referred to in 1 Corinthians 5:11, and doing everything in love

Philemon: One in Christ

Bob Cornwall on Abounding in Love and First Things

AJR highlighted a new book about temple language in 1 Corinthians and another about divine politics and polemics in Paul’s letters

Michael Kruger on the “righteousness of God” in the 1984 edition of the NIV

Charles Savelle shared about a new commentary on Romans, as well as multiple posts about Colossians.

Interview with Luke Timothy Johnson in The Christian Century

“Put on the Full Armor of God”: Applying Ephesians 6:10-18

Podcast on Voices and Views on Paul

What Was Paul’s Thorn In The Flesh?

Slides on Galatians: Paul’s most urgent letter

Apostle of Persuasion– Part One

Apostle of Persuasion— Part Two

Apostle of Persuasion– Part Three

Apostle of Persuasion– Part Four

Apostle of Persuasion— Part Five

That series continues on Ben’s blog. From Ian Paul:

How should we preach on St Paul’s exhortations?

Was Paul a Universalist?

Allan Bevere on Paul as ambassador

Not brand new but still worth sharing:

Why the apostle Paul was in prison so often

 


Browse Our Archives

Close Ad